Warning - they are selling 10 year old wine.
I purchased from their December case sale. I sampled some wine and bought 18 bottles to give away for Christmas and serve at Christmas. Having sampled the wine I thought I knew what I was giving my manager, friends, and family.
In January, I opened a bottle of Loyalist red, that came from the above 18 I purchased. It immediately smelt like vinegar, and there was tons of sentiment in it. I didn’t want to jump to conclusions and assumed it was a bad batch - it happens.
Since then I’ve tried 2-3 more bottles that were all the same in vinegar taste and full of sentiment. I read the bottle and it was bottled in 2010 - 10 years ago!!!!!
LCBO only sells bottles up to 2 years old; unless of course it’s a vintage. Even so, most vintages are aged in a barrel and not a bottle. We spoke with Puddicombe and they said their wine only gets better with age - but clearly not since we first noticed the taste was off prior to even knowing the age of the wine.
The loyalist white is from 2015, and Starbust from 2013. So far, all the bottles I opened of those were fine.
It’s just embarrassing for me to have given my manager, friends and family decade old cheap wine that tastes like vinegar and sentiment. This is what I served at Christmas.
I get that Puddicombe wants to clear out wine, which was the reason for the case sale. But come on, 10 years? Did you find these in the basement somewhere? Shame on you.