Reviews of Old School Pizza Co. (Restaurant)

Morse Farms

Absolutely amazing! So delicious!!! I use to work at a pizza place where we would make a taco after hours... there Tex mex pizza tops it! Will definitely be ordering from here again ❤️

Rilee Steckler

Hands down, best pizza in town!! Actually, best restaurant in town! To the reviewers who mentioned the “ash” on the bottom of the pizza, or the …

Lynne McCausland

My pizza got burnt and took a while to get but all n all tasted like a pizza should

Edward H

Great new pizza shop in St. Thomas. It is a bit more expensive but it is a quality pizza. The sauce has a touch of spice so not sure if the kids will like it.

Bill Inger

Great pizza, interesting flavours

Jason McGuire

One of the best pies ever in life ...not jking

H

Friendly staff, fresh hot pizza! AMAZING!

Kelly Mckay

This was our first time ordering and we were extremely pleased with the pizza. Great crust and toppings combinations. We got the hot honey pepperoni and the buff both were so flavourful, the crust was nice and airy. I do prefer a thinner …

Daysie Laing

Best gluten free crust in town. The cheeseburger pizza is excellent

John Rempel

Everytime we order, we try to order something we haven't tried yet and we have never been disappointed. Excellent food and excellent service.

Tim Janzen

Amazing pizza with tons of toppings! Highly recommend for any pizza lovers...

Heather Stern

The absolute best gluten free pizza ever! And done with every safety for my health! You would never know it was gluten free and I love their sauce! The family had regular pizza and said also- best pizza ever!

Justin Barfett

Ordered early in the afternoon and the pizza was ready for pickup right on time! The combination of spicy and sweet on the "hot honey pepperoni" was amazing, with a little sweet on the crust to finish out the slice. 10/10 can't wait to get it again, thanks!

Kevin Frank

Just ordered tonight for the first time I really enjoyed it the pizza was really good lots of toppings the customer service was top-notch they were polite and very helpful I would recommend this place

KP Cosplays

I can hands down say this is the best pizza I had EVER had. The Garlic bread is the bomb, this place is absolutely amazing! I'm not usually a crust eater either but I would never let any of this go to waste... highly recommend!

Mike Foley

This place is awesome. Great friendly service, awesome menu and delicious pizza! The decor is great and a very clean establishment. The TexMex pizza is amazing! Pizza crust is amazing! Gluten free and vegan options are available which …

Alarick Mueller

Too bad there isn't a 6 star review.... All we could say is ....WoW I can't remember the last time I had a pizza that was so good.... If ever ? Hands down the best pizza in town !

Brandon Norman

I enjoyed their pizza.

Felicia Maximin

BEST pizza I've EVER had. OMG! I had the Pickle Pizza and asked them to add chicken. A pregnant woman's dream come true. Pickles on pizza ????. Ill be back for sure. Thank you Old School Pizza! Nailed it!

Jason teixeira (Codtube)

Best pizza I've ever had!

Lisa Churchill

This pizza is delicious. Wood fired oven. Crispy great tasting crust. Lots of cheese and fresh toppings. Great flavour. Highly recommend

Hassan Hammoud

I just ordered the ???? on a Friday night called ahead of time because they get busy on Fridays and Saturdays but let me tell you I ordered one small supreme ????and a small dill pickle ????and WOWWWW. I never thought a ????with dill pickles on it would be good but I was wrong it was simply amazing plenty of toppings. I was amazed on how well the dill pickle ????tasted with its own sauce. It was cooked perfectly and the crust is absolutely amazing. if you're thinking of ordering ????and was wondering how this new ???? parlor is all I got to say is order up cuz you will be very satisfied with the outcome.

Don S

Pizza was not good.

Philip Mulkins

The freshest tasting pizza around.

Michael Inman

Have ordered take out here twice, already planning what I want next. Their dough is, dare I say, perfect. The tomato sauce is also amazing. Toppings are fresh (see: real pineapple). The cook on the pizza has been consistently great. Have …

Jesse Niles

Meal type

Andrew McCarthy

Amazing pizza and friendly staff!!

Colin Burton

Me and pizza are basically synonymous at this point and let me tell you that this is the best pizza I have ever had in my entire life. I have tried (devoured single-handedly) the classic deluxe and the Bacon Cheeseburger pizza and both were …

Matt Kroeker

By far the BEST pizza in St Thomas and area, you can taste the difference of the high quality ingredients and the wood oven. Don’t waste your time anywhere else, this is the place to go for awesome PIZZA !!!

Amanda Trudeau

The pizza would have been fantastic but my pizza's, like every other pizza I saw in there during my visit, had burnt crust

timothy sullivan

Friendly staff. One of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. Real wood-fired pizza! This place doesn’t skimp on toppings and the sauce is very flavourful. I’ll return . . . perhaps tomorrow!✨

Leszek Przywara

Worth the drive all the way from London to check out these magnificently creative flavours. Pizza crust is astounding thanks to the wood-fired ovens (imported from Italy). The baking process "nukes" the pizza just above 700 degrees and that …

Judy Earhart

This is awesome pizza. It will me go to in St. Thomas.

Bethany Schievink

When I called to ordered the staff was pleasant. The place was very clean and and trendy looking with Fast service. I ordered a large cheese pizza with jalapeños on the side. It was delicious and the crust of the pizza was fluffy and light.I will order from here again.

gtmustang2010ont

The best gluten free/dairy free pizza in town! They allow you to preorder, provide friendly service and incredible pizza!! THANK YOU

Jordan “jordantrizz” Arthur

If you haven't had wood fired pizza before, then you need to check this place out. Once of the best pizza in St Thomas, ingredients and dough is super fresh. Go at lunch time, get a 9" personal and you'll get a dollar off. Will return!

Randy T. Killey

So much oil on the pizza

Gothic Girl

Great customer service, delicious pizza, and they pay great attention to gluten-free orders. A+

Karen Elsdon

The best pizza ever. ???? ????‍♀️✨

Jules Fern

Truly a 10 star establishment. This place is new to St. Thomas, and they have been destroying the wood fire pizza game from the first day they opened. They are family owned & probably some of the most kind hearted customer service folks …

Skippywilcox -

10/10 Recommend

Grant Street

Great pizza...so impressed! Will be back!

Adam W.

Amazing pizza

Ben Hunter

Service

Mor Gan

It was so delicious! Starting with the crust being so light to the toppings being plentiful with so much flavor. Love unique ideas for pizza.

Dave Stanic

Very tasty pizza!!

Carla Snobelen

Best pizza in town!!!

Jeff Montgomery

I ordered the "ivegotyourback911" pulled pork pizza. What a fantastic pizza, pork was moist and tasty. Crust fresh and really good! But most importantly a local company supporting another local company and first responder organization. I will order another for sure, well done Old School Pizza!!!!

Tori s

Okay, super pizza critic here and I can't say enough positive things about this place! It is literally the best pizza in town (sorry everyone else) this will always be my first choice at this point. So happy you exist Old School!

Chris Elsdon

Normally don't post reviews but have to today! We had the jalapeño Popper pizza with garlic fingers and the tex mex salad and it was awesome!! No more second rate pizza places for this family!!

kronos555666

Excellent pizza, and real bacon YUM! This place smells so good when you walk in, makes you hungry

Rebecca Northcott

Loved going here. One of the best pizzas we have had. Fresh out of the oven. Brought to us at our table. Staff really kind and helpful. Best ate fresh but all the family had some and all agreed it was a delight. Seconds were given. We will be back!

Craig Heywood

THE best pizza in St Thomas/London area. Real bacon, generous toppings. Everything about these pizzas and the staff is a 10. I will never go back to the big chains again.

Jeanine Topping

Pizza here was really good.

Kailyn Faith

the only thing OLD is the age of the pizza that was so stale

Jim McCoomb

The wood fired oven pizza is the best, traditional methods as pizza is meant to be. Great selection at a reasonable price!

Amanda Vandenwyngaert

Ordered lunch for me and my son today, we both loved it right from the first bite to the last . And yes we finished the whole thing! It literally took 15 min from the time I ordered for it to be ready right at the lunch rush. Great job. We will be back soon! ????

K C

Very very good pizza. I've only tried their donair pizza and the bacon cheeseburger and both were very good. I think a big mac style sauce would be better on the bacon cheeseburger pizza though wink wink. Staff was friendly, and the wood burning ovens smell nice when you walk in. Definitely recommended and will be returning.

Andrew Brown

Tried it for the first time and was not disappointed. Staff was super friendly when ordering and picking up. The pizzas were delicious and amazing quality.

Jen Eden

Really good gluten free pizza and the dill pickle pizza is also really good. Definitely a must try for anyone eating gluten free looking for a good pizza

Andy Whitcroft

2nd time ordering. Just as good as the first. Very impressed with Old School and we’ll keep coming back.

Moira Metcalfe

Best pizza in St. Thomas without question. Fresh, hot and wood fired; perfect crust. Do yourself a favour and add garlic fingers, they’re the bees knees.

Devon McKeown

Meal type

Roberto Pearson

Take out

Christina Bilton

I haven't had a better pizza anywhere. Lots to choose from. Unique ideas and toppings like honey drizzle, a must try!

James Yeaman

I love a good brick oven pizza with a nice charred crust. Little pricier and not my go to but definitely worth it now and again. Freindly staff.

Deanna Fox

We just moved to St. Thomas last week, and were super excited when we drove by this place. Tried it last night, and the food is simply amazing! Super fresh, and cooked perfectly - we asked for well done, and they delivered the perfect pizzas! We had the Supreme and the Spicy Thai, and wow - we can't wait to try some more!

Dan Loosley

This is amazing ????, had the garlic chicken pizza and will make the trip from London to get more. Quality products, great service, fresh ingredients. Wow. Also wood fired its great. Dave Portnoy would give it over an 8! Guaranteed. Gotta try it.

J M

Delicious pizza, wood fire is so much better than the conveyor belt oven! More of an authentic pizza crust.

Devon Sampson

I had an existential crisis after eating this pizza for the first time. Like…why can’t all pizza places be this good? High quality ingredients and time-honoured cooking techniques. It’s simple but it’s perfect. …

Marcel Berthault

Best pizza in town!

J H

Please bring a location to Niagara! A coworker and I tried a couple small pizzas when we were working out of town. The wood fire pizza is fantastic. Would recommend for sure. Good restaurant for takeout or eating in. Restaurant looked very clean and organized.

Craig Stevenson

Amazing.

Trevor D

Consistently delicious pizza

Gary Meredith

Tried old school pizza tonight, 3 bites in and already regret it. Pizza was burnt and tasted as such. Bottom of pizza covered in ash. Hands were black after eating. I get that its a fire oven and some of this is natural in the process but oven could be cleaned better and maybe don't put pizzas so close to the fire or less cooking time.

A J

Take out

Jeff Bullas

All three pizzas were delicious but the creamy dill pickle pizza is supposed to have a drizzle of garlic aioli which was missing. Was looking forward to that one the most :(

Les Knott

First time trying and loved it. Everything was delicious!

Lesley Jim Mitchell

We picks up two pizzas on Saturday and ate them 3 hours later and the next day, BEST PIZZA I'VE HAD IN YEARS! Spicy Thai is my favorite!

Colton Homewood

Great pizza. Vegan option was terrific. Curbside pick up. Fast, on time.

Yvonne Taylor

Great pizza. You won't be disappointed!

Claire Hamm

The pizza is amazing. Honestly some of the best pizza I've ever had.

Jordan Murphy

Name sais it all, old school pizza done really well!

S Johnston

The pizza was great! Love the char on the wood fired crust. Tried samples of 4 different from the best in class. Locomotive, Twisted garlic chicken, Bacon cheeseburger, and Hot honey pepperoni. I would order them all again. My only knock against this restaurant is that it is expensive.

Wendy Wendy

Amazing pizza hands down best pizza in st Thomas. Once you try it you will never go back to regular Pizza. I can promise you that.

Megan Henderson

Your pizza is amazing!!! We had the cheese burger pizza and the chicken casserole pizza. They were enjoyed by all.

Jimmy Jj

Dinner

Dan Roy

My wife and I enjoyed this pizza. One it was a great value. Two a unique flavorful tomato sauce. The was not overwhelming and compliments the toppings. all in all the best pizza in St Thomas. …

Michelle Heslop

One of the best pizza spots in town and not absurd prices where they could definitely do that. Check them out!

Tyler McLellan

Very good pizza but you need to plan ahead! Order at 3pm or 4pm to get it for dinner time. It is worth it!

Rob Hardy

Was trying to hold off writing a review until we received a order that wasn't top notch. …

Robert MacMenamin

Some of the best pizza around hands down. Really fresh and well made. Love the creative pizza options available.

Renee Trevors

Just tried Old School Pizza tonight. AMAZING!! Will definitely order again. Everything about our meal from ordering to pickup was easy and staff was very polite. Great job Everyone.

Calvin Hosie

Delicious pizza! Haven’t tried one I haven’t loved!

candice williston

Favorite pizza place hands down The texmex pizza is my favorite! …

Anne Ashfield

Lots of interesting combinations to try. I've had one (chicken bacon ranch). Lots to go. My new favourite.

Nicole Verhoeven

Awesome pizza!! Great service!!

Cait C

Hands down the best pizza we’ve ever had. Fresh toppings, delicious sauce, and a crunchy crust that just tastes so dang good. Will definitely be coming back, and have already told everyone we know to try it too!

Janessa Palmer

Best pizza in town!

Laura Incognito

Their pizza is incredible! I had no idea that my life was missing dill pickle pizzas until I tried theirs. Will definitely be getting pizza from there from now on!

Sook Chang

Dinner

Amber Durdle

Pizza was alright. New style in town. The smokey flavour the oven provides to the pizza just wasn't my style.

Holly MacQuarrie

We had the text mex pizza and the Thai pizza and I honestly can't get back there soon enough to try all of the rest. Specialty pizzas at its finest. …

Amy Rowland

Clean, friendly pizza joint. You walk in and the smokey bacon smell is enough to make your mouth water. The crust is regular thickness, crispy, smokey and delicious. The sauce is delicious, fresh toppings, lots of cheese, the mushrooms were 2 thumbs up. Way to go Old school! Definitely will order here again!

Charles Bakker

I am editing the review I gave for this establishment 9 months ago. And my reason for doing so is because, after all this time, my wife and I are still blown away by this place!! We have now visited many times, and tried many different …

David Lawrence

Best pizza I've had in a long time

Timothy Lui

Really good, I really love there spicy Thai I know I will be getting it again, and the people there are really friendly.

Mark and Lisa McIntosh

Bacon double Cheeseburger Pizza was awesome! The crust is delicious too.????????????????

Adam Mark

Excellent pizza!

Chad Kivisto

First time ordering. classic cheese, creamy dill pickle, and a hot honey pepperoni. I can’t say that I have ever had better pizza!

RyeWilkes

Excellent gormet pizza

larry banman

That was amazing pizza, full of cheese and toppings not bread. Not to date myself too badly but I have to quote Neil Diamond... "I'm a believer"

Karli Ideson

Yes super clean, but I would be wary of so few reviews to call this place fantastic. My pizza was just okay and I say this as someone that has eaten lots of pizza in several countries. PizzaWorx is a better local option and not as pricey.

Adrian Peters

Best Pizza in town. Period.

AJ R.

Old School Pizza is our new go-to for pizza in St. Thomas! Every pizza we’ve tried has been delicious!! We can’t wait to try them all! ????

Geoff Hebb

Fresh toppings, tons of cheese and cooked in a wood burning oven. Bit pricey, but you get what you pay for.

Dan Hawco

The best pizza I have ever eaten will keep coming back nice staff as well

Colin Chewter

Best Pizza is St Thomas by a landslide. After Capris closed down there wasn’t a great pizza option but old school pizza is awesome and reheats awesome for lunch the next day!

The WELD shop

Service

Dylan Murphy

First Time trying this pizza. We are from out of town. Was the best pizza we have had in an extremely long time. We will for sure be making the drive for our pizza night to this place. We got the cheeseburger pizza. Which was incredible …

Andrew Fleming

Great loved the bacon cheeseburger pizza!

Kia

Incredible pizza. The new unequivocal BEST pizza in St. Thomas. I am actually blown away at how delicious their pizzas are. Such unique toppings, smokey from the wood fire, and absolutely delicious every time. They text when your order is …

Jessica A

Best damn pizza in st thomas, no questions asked. The quality of the pizza is outta of this world. Keep it guys. Don't ever shut down, I don't know what I'd do with out your pizza in my life.

JUNE BASKIN

Excellent!!!

Ken Roberts

The bedt pizza anywhere

lorisimpson1

Wow -- glad we found the "Old School Pizza Co" while exploring St Thomas options for our new pizza place -- it will now be our "go to place". The variety of toppings are very creative and delicious -- so far have only tried the …

Cheryl Boudreau

I normally don't write bad reviews but I have never experienced service this terrible. Have had their pizza before and they always made a very good pizza. However, the other weekend my husband picked up the pizza and there was a long hair in it and it was not gluten free crust like we ordered. My husband also said that the older gentleman up front was grossly rude to his coworkers. I am very disappointed in what this establishment has become and will no longer be purchasing from here.

Kim Hurd

Love the cheeseburger pizza it's amazing.

J L

Best pizza in St. Thomas by a landslide!! Extremely tasty and very reasonably priced.

Danielle W.

Good.

Matt Portiss

Will never order from anywhere else again!

Krystal Degalan

Pizza was delicious! I tried a few of their different pizzas all were awesome but my favorite was the spicy thai chicken! highly recommend Old school pizza co. You wont be disappointed.

Emilie Marceau

New favourite pizza place! Super clean and super delicious. Their menu is unique with offerings like no other pizza place around here. They even had a whole page of veggie pizzas! Crust is amazing and my pizza had so many toppings. Yum!