Reviews of Crafted 1885 (Restaurant)

Nathan Van Natter

Always fantastic food. Been through most of the menu and looking forward to Seconds.

Rachel Holierhoek

We had smoothies and milkshakes and they were delicious! Highly recommend this spot. Staff was also very nice and welcoming. Can’t wait to see this place flourish! Maybe some picnic tables and string lights outside would be a nice touch! Can’t wait to come back again!

kitty lover 7

Wonderful service, generous servings, and the prices are good, too!

Michael Holden

Omg excellent

Sean McCooey

Amazing food for the whole family. Tried for the first time today and it’s my new to go place in Fort Erie. Awesome place true to Fort Erie.

M G

Got a Buffalo chicken salad and poutine. Salad was amazing. I was surprised how well the sweet pickles went with everything. They didn't skimp on the toppings. This salad was loaded. Poutine was great - reminded me of Smokes Poutinery. Will definitely be back! Staff are so friendly.

Georgia Metcalfe Tripp

Subs are wonderful but I'd like to see it better laid out. Whether it be a bigger bun or just layer it so you everything in one bite not all toppings then all meat but still wonderful

Kevin Hesse

Yum!

Kevin S

tonight we ordered subs they say 10 minutes. they were so cold its like they took the out of the fridge. they were supposed to be hot. steak and other chicken. worst ever.

John S

Dinner

J Bindon

Great food and great prices. Their Tex Mex Dorito Crunch salad and sub are amazing

Vader 97

This is the restaurant Fort Erie needs. Staff and service were great. Portion size was way more than expected. If you’re in the area you need to check this place out!

Taboo .Textiles

Service

Arianna Canavan

Wife likes it. Me, not so much.

Lisa Gely

Great sub , you get what you pay for!!!!

Paul Diamond

Friendly service, large portions and delicious poutine. I highly recommend it....bring your appetite or a friend to help you finish the huge portions.

Miss Klassen

Check out this beast of a sandwich! Got the assorted and it was great. Look at that meat stack!

Bennett Garner

I like this place for all of the different foods, and also the choice of toppings.

Michelle Blais

Subs are amazing staff is sooo friendly

Daniel Turner (Dansaturner)

Amazing food and shakes friendly service..love it!

Justin E

Well made with staff of young local people. Shop local.

motherofdragons forever

Awesome! The subs were great, milkshakes were fabulous! Fresh fresh... this is a must try. We had the meatball sub and the Tex Mex, dorito sub! Electric ???? Mango shake and Maple shake! Yummy

heather dennis

I admit when I seen the prices online I was thinking that seems expensive for a sub, but after getting my food I was impressed, it was worth every penny.

Scott Wedlake

Food was ok. Was worth a try. But with health and safety handle food with glove not bare hands if so wash every time after handling food prep. But place is worth a look and support for just opening up in time of covid give them support

George Burgman

Amazing food and friendly service!

Sterner

What a clean and cheerful snack and sandwich place just off the Friendship Trail. Get off at Crescent or Buffalo and head north o e very short block. BEST peach milkshake EVER. Freshly made, real ingredients! Fries superb, huge portions!

Sam Hancock

First visit today. I had a philly sub & husband had assorted sub & classic potene fries. Both subs were delicious. Could not believe the amount of meat in the subs. We will definitely be back to try out other food on menu. Staff was very friendly.

Lorena Rosettani

You gotta eat here!! ????

Aarzoo

Best Sub i have ever tried...specially milkshakes are to die for????and poutine is just amazing. LOVED IT????

A.R.I

AMAZING food... Great prices.. friendly staff.. We are so happy to have a great new place to eat in Fort Erie

Cristine Sousa

Just had the steak sub. Last week the assorted, both were excellent and the staff were very friendly. I will definitely come back.

Wendy Thompson

Had the Chicken Bacon Ranch sub here last week. It was very very tasty. Was pretty busy when I went around lunch hour. Well worth the try!

Hannah

First time there I ordered a blt there was only a couple pieces of bacon so only tasted the bread and cheese but it was very fresh and I ordered a strawberry shortcake smoothie but it tasted like a normal strawberry but very good none the less I will be going back to trying some of the poutines I am a poutine freak so are my kids so we will be going back!!!! Super clean and super friendly!!!

Kirsty MacKay

Visited for the first time last week and was very impressed! The subs were delicious and staff are very friendly. All the ingredients were fresh and everything is reasonably priced. I'm looking forward to trying the salads and poutine soon!

Kelly Byer

Very friendly staff. Food is awesome.

Amy Hawley (Panchali)

Great little local place! Food is excellent for the price and has a great mix of quality and quantity. So far I've had a meatball sub and a bacon chicken poutine, both were great! I have yet to try the loganberry banana milkshake but with what I've seen so far I surely wont be disappointed. With it's homely atmosphere it very much feels like you're ordering from a friend. They went above and beyond to provide excellent customer service.

Jordan Kovacs

Excellent across the board . Very fresh, we ordered the crescent park club and veggie class , bother excellent . Fries were great , can’t wait to try their poutines

Debbie Flemington

We love this place! The people who work there, the subs, the salads... but the poutine is my favourite. And the customer service is amazing!

Paul Horvath

Asked for a assorted sub and got all ham

J. Winger

been there three times, had a different sub each time, buffalo chicken my favourite awesome food

Chris Clow

Heard so many good things. Tried it tonight ( 2subs) very impressed with staff, location and taste.. Called it first a fort erie hidden gem. I will make sure to tell everyone to try the food here. Way to go.

Rocky Maui

Buffalo chicken poutine is EXTREMELY good. You do have to wait 20-30minutes but it's worth it. The only thing is that there strawberry shortcake really tastes like strawberry banana smoothie.

R G

Portions seem decreased in size in subs since new owners. Taste still delicious. Not enough toppings.

Nicole L’Heureux

We enjoy the friendly staff and good food

eric halkes

Absolutely delicious! We ate at Crafted 1885 today and the staff were very friendly! I had a Philly steak sub that was delicious and I couldn’t believe the amount of meat on the sub! My husband had the Buffalo chicken bacon ranch salad and it was huge and delicious! We will definitely come here again, we highly recommend it.

Kelsey Macneil

Friendly staff great food, fresh sub buns and awesome soup.

Joanne Maloney

Great local place! Super tasty and great service!

Kathryn Zanutto

I had smoked meat poutine, hubby had Philly steak sub. Both of us had peach paradise. Everything was delicious!

Greg Gwynne

Always delicious food and friendly staff.

Kathy McKean

text mex dorito crunch sub was amazing and very filling. my daughter had the chicken fingers and fries and said they are the best fingers shes ever had. will def be a repeat customer.

Nathan G

Went in for my first visit tonight based off a recommendation from family and I'm definitely glad I went in! Extremely friendly staff who are more than happy to answer any question you might have. I got 2 subs thinking I would be able to eat both after a long day...I was wrong! Value for the portion size is unmatched and the quality of the bread, meat, and ingredients make this restaurant one that I will definitely be coming back to again in the future. Cheers Crafted, you just earned yourself a loyal customer!

Chris

So good. New place. Subs and more. Incredible service.

Sheila Papoulidis

Great place owners are awesome and the food is outstanding

Daya Mccumber

Food was delicious and great portions. I had the steak sub and wife had a philly steak salad. Great job. Will order from here again without hesitation, very friendly.

Karen FitzPatrick

Fresh food..amazing owners. I want to try it all. Tex Mex salad is the best!

Louis Nigro

Found their website... not detailed enough on the menu to know what I was getting but I went and ordered anyway. Fabulous poutine. Got pulled pork and philly steak. Very good. Hubby made it through his but I struggled to get past the 1/2 way mark. We will try more now that I can see a better version of the menu after getting a paper copy. Only suggestion is detail it as much on your website for new people just finding you. Google had a better menu on my phone for you while i was standing in line.

Shawn Lyle

Try it if you haven't yet!

Kayla W

Love the food here, and the staff is super friendly. It’s always fresh and delicious, and you get a good amount of food for your money.

Shannon S

Great food, friendly staff!

Vanessa Kush

best poutine I've ever had in my life. I got the spicier buffalo chicken bacon poutine & just ... YUM!. was totally worth the drive, even with the current price of fuel haha =)

Jess VV

Great food and super friendly staff!!!

Selina Ogden

I went to this restaraunt for the first time today after hearing good word of mouth in a facebook group. When i got there i walked into a bright clean establishment where the staff was friendly and helpful. What i assune was the owner was speaking to me about how they make their own buns and use local food sources. You could hear the passion for hia business when he spoke. And it was with sincere excitement and pride that he spoke. When i got home i realized they had forgotten one sub i called and they immediately knew and apologized. Then they offered to deliver it. Not even 10 min later the same man shows up at my door apologized and handed me my sub. Their customer service and how they handled it was amazing and gracious. Now lets talk about the food. We ordered a pizza sub, a buffalo chicen bacon, a dorito crunch and a philly steak and poutines and naked fries. . OMG !!! They were literally the best subs we have ever had. And i dont think i have had a philly sub ever that was stuffed so full of meat and toppings. The fries are the perfect golden fries like u get from a chip wagon. Soooo good and the poutine was delicious. Way to go crafted 1885 a great job. Well done. I look forward to eating here for many years to come.

Tim O

Meal type

Dianne Conte

First experience. My wife had the Classic Poutine. Unfortunately, the fries weren't cooked, they were raw in the middle and pure white. But...everything else we ordered was delicious, well priced for portion, and the staff is super friendly. I'm sure the owners are new to the restaurant world, and it was busy. That being said, I look forward to returning for a second chance, and to bump those stars up. We needed a place like this is Fort Erie and I wish you nothing but success! I initially gave 3 stars, but the fact I'm seeing other reviews after mine replied to by the owner, yet my review left unaddressed. I found very unprofessional and dropped to 1 star.

Mary Rousseau

Take out

H M

Great subs!! I would definitely say they have the best chocolate shake I have ever had!! So chocolatey!

Jason Collee

There is lots to choose from but we've only had subs so for and they are awesome, milkshakes are so yummy and the people are so kind and friendly. Give it a try you won't be disappointed

Beeej Shears

Stopped into this new restaurant in Fort Erie for a take out lunch. They practice proper Covid etiquette with of course masks, and Good social distancing rules. Both my friend and I got the Tex Mex Dorito Crunch salad. I also had to try the “naked” fries, and I had a loganberry and banana smoothie. Both my friend and I loved the salads. It comes with ground beef, crumbled Dorito chips, sour cream and salsa, then you can add stuff like cheese, tomatoes, various types of peppers, olives and other veggies. Several dressing choices. I added cheese, cucumbers, and tomatoes, with chipotle dressing. There was a generous supply of ground beef, lots of crunchy Doritos, and the dressing had a bit of a bite. I will definitely have it again. My friend had the ranch dressing and was equally impressed. As I am not a fan of poutine (even though I grew up in Quebec ????), I had the plain fries. I am a huge fan of Quebec greasy, creamy fries twice cooked in ancient beef tallow. That’s not these. They were ok, but a bit dry. Well cooked ( I hate it when fries are hard in the centre) but they don’t have the distinctive Quebec tang. Still, they might be better when served as poutine, since the gravy would likely work with the slightly dry texture. The smoothie was delicious. Can’t wait to try a milkshake next time!

Carolyn Day

Bacon Chicken Ranch -100% Yummy! Will definitely go again. Great service, Great Team and delicious food.