Reviews of The Lobster Shack (Fish Shop)

Hossein Salimian

We tried every lobster roll in the area, and this was by far the best. The lobster roll was delicious, warm buttery bread with a generous amount of lobster for the price. The staff were friendly and the service was excellent.

Julie Nicholson

The best classic lobster roll I have ever eaten. Beautiful location to enjoy a meal in.

Maryam

The lobster roll tastes great and the lobster plater is also good for reasonable prices.

Carolyne

I ordered a 12 oysters platter. And one of those was gone. It was the worst moment of my culinary life. ????

Andre Macinnis

Great food, friendly staff, yearly stop

Sara Maude Couture Guimond

The lobster roll was amazing :) the best meal since I'm on PEI!

Connie Hubbs

Lobster roll to die for and local ale in the fridge! Eat outside & get a $2.00 ice cream cone next door. (Different business)

J H

Amazing lobster rolls...just the right amount of ingredients while leaving plenty room to experience the natural flavour of the lobster in a toasted bread which made the experience extra special.

Mike Lavigne

Great lobster roll, just lobster no fillers.

Michael Vasilev

Best lobster roll we’ve had so far!

Shawn Hines

IMHO one of the best lobster rolls on the East side of the island. Simple and delicious.

Dem

I had the lobster grilled cheese. Best thing I've ever put in my mouth. I still dream about that sandwich. 100% will tell everyone about this place.

Tayyab Pirzada

The lobster was way better than I thought it would be.

Joshua Biggley

Excellent food, amazingly fresh oysters, tourist prices

Tex ican

We found this spot on the way back from East Point Lighthouse. It is so good! Visiting the island we knew that oysters and lobsters were going to be on the menu. We started the trip at an oyster house and when we got here, we were told that there is a distinct difference between a "lobster dinner" and a "lobster roll"...each worthy of experiencing. When we drove by this beach we saw the sign and thought, "why not try it?" We are so glad we did!! It won the 2019 best lobster roll award (we found out once we went inside) and for good reason! $15 for a fantastic lobster roll. The bun was perfectly toasted and had the feel of what we used to call "fluffy white bread." It was stuffed with a huge amount of lobster salad, and came with a side of sweet pickles and potato chips. They also sell live & frozen lobsters as well as bulk unshucked oysters. (They do sell shucked oysters too - I had 1/2 dozen and loved them! We're already planning to go back one more time before we head home!

Norman Davie

Really Good lobster roll and grilled cheese sandwich

Jon Careless

Excellent lobster rolls and raw oysters.

Shelly Flora

Best clams I ever had

Brittany Ross

Great place to stop and have a lobster roll while you enjoy a beer and the ocean!

Ahmed

Amazing lobster rolls!! The perfect meal after the beach

Jay Jay

Awesome food special thanks to chef richard.

Orville Elliston

Lobster Roll was probably half the size you'd get at Richard's. The taste was also quite basic

Alfred Leung

Tasty lobster roll. Nice view. Quick service.

Nozomi K

I shared lobster roll platter and steamed softshell clams. My partner had 6 oysters on top. We paid around 55 dollars. Lobster roll came with chips and pickles. The taste was well balanced with buttered bread. I wanted to eat more if I didn't have anything else. Clams are big and flavorful (cooked with celery and onions). Seasonings are very simple for both which I could taste the seafood itself. It was a great find!

Alexandra Duchemin

Although the lobster roll was good, I was upset with the way I was treated. I was yelled at to go outside because there were too many people in the building. Then later when my friends and I were eating we were told "the garbage is over there girls!" In a manner that suggested we were going to leave all our garbage on the table. There were other people eating outside who were not told this. We are not children. It was a group of five 22-23 year old women with university degrees. We were not going to litter. And although I am officially a NB resident I have a cottage near Souris. My parents love it at the Lobster Shack but I won't be back.

Lynn Liao

Excellent oysters and lobster roll. Nice outdoor seating right by a splash pad and playground.

Jing Cao

So delicious with the beautiful beach views

Scott Keefe

Wowee !!! This place is awesome!!!

Brian symborski

Best place for a lobster roll on the island.

James Biernat

The Lobster roles are to DIE for and the Muscles are just as good! Wow!

L S

Delicious lobster roll

Mosaic N

(Translated) Best lobster roll I have eaten. Excellent and generous on the portions, well done! (Original) Meilleur lobster roll que j'ai mangé. Excellent et généreux sur les portions, bravo!

sylvie cayouette

(Translated) Very good lobster roll. (Original) Lobster roll très bon.

Colin Barrett

Best lobster roll I have ever had. The gentleman that waited on us was absolutely fantastic.

Terry Parkin

It was a highly mediocre weather day when we arrived at the Lobster Shack. We had read all the favourable reviews and were looking forward to experiencing some delicious seafood ourselves, they did not disappoint. We had steamed lobster, clams and lobster roll. All were fantastic, cooked perfect and reasonably priced. Next time in PEI we will definitely revisit, but we'll try for better weather.

He ling Guei

(Translated) Lobster rolls are delicious, the meat is quite tender (Original) 龍蝦捲好吃，肉蠻嫩的

Iroka Richardson

It wasn't that bad but it is too small for that money

Birt MacKinnon

Very very good food

ReelData Inc.

The most delicious lobster roll and oysters l I have ever had! The beach offered a beautiful view while we ate. The staff was extremely friendly and helpful as well.

Denis Gelinas

(Translated) Sublime lobster roll (1st experience for me). Good beers to go with it all. Beautiful view of the sea (gulf) (Original) Guedille au homard sublime (1ère expérience pour moi). Bonnes bières pour accompagner le tout. Belle vue sur la mer (golfe)

Jake Szczechura

Best lobster roll I've ever had. Grilled cheese platter was disappointing, but that's not what the restaurant is for.

M. N.

Visited 9/17/2019 from Kingston ON. I had the lobster roll platter - my first lobster roll. It was loaded with lobster and just lightly dressed with mayo and a sprinkling of paprika - just what I was hoping for as I didn't fancy some kind of lobster 'salad' loaded with mayo and veg. Probably best value on island at $14.95. Hubby had grilled cheese, not being a lobster fan. Great deck overlooking the water. Definitely recommend.

darlene valdivia

Disappointing, first whole lobster in PEI. It was extremely watery. Surprised it is only served with a dinner roll and a few pickles. Not worth the money

Erin X

The best lobster and oysters we had in P.E.I! The dining deck overlooks a beautiful, quiet beach that's perfect for a little walk after.