Reviews of Orillia Italian Gelato and Market (Fish Shop)

Z LLL

They have different flavors every day. I like all flavors I tried. Tartofu is also pretty tasty. Be aware that Google map shows the store is closed at 9 pm but actually it closes at 8 pm.

Marci Csumrik

Finally!! A local spot to enjoy Gelato & other delicious Italian foods. I picked up some pasta & sauce and it did not dissapoint!!

Carolyn Tomkins

Amazing little gem downtown Orillia! We had the dairy and gluten free lemon sorbet and also picked up a jar of sun dried tomatoes. Both were excellent and we can’t wait to come back!

Angela Closs

Got the rice balls. Very disappointed. Wernt homemade and very small.

Monica Cain

Excellent service very friendly staff

Lena Lozinski

Delicious cannolis!!! Will definitely be ordering/returning again!

Patrick Lameront

Good selection of premium quality ingredients and a warm family owned atmosphere. Very welcoming and helpful service. The gelato was rich and tasty. Absolutely worth a visit on a hot summers day.

Paula Dukhan

Great tiramisu gelato. friendly staff and they also had great pasta sauce that was a 10.

Johnny Hub

Man!! Their Pistachio Gelato is too good! Must try!

Terry St.Louis

Flavours rotate, but liked everyone I had so far

chantal smith

Excellent client service. Great response time on Facebook . Gelato is amazing. Have also purchased some of the pasta sauces which did not disappoint. Have been several times in the short time they've been open. strongly recommend!

Joey Sarcinella

Awesome gelato! We love the quaint store. They also carry traditional Italian products that are hard to find. Different flavors all the time that have all been great! Great addition to our community!

Ro Maassy

Yummy gelato, had lots of Italian products. Perfect little store I'd definitely check out again.

Georgia Gray

Cute store. Great Gelato. Nice workers.

Todd Blair

Would not recommend! Ordered an Italian Champ and Chicken Parm sandwiches. I have to say, the Italian Champ was basically a Ciabatta Bun with a piece of ham, and perhaps a piece of capicola and a tiny bit of cheese. That's it. And the Chicken parm tasted like frozen chicken fingers on a stale bun with some marinara sauce that didn't add much, just made it soggy. I really wish I could right a better review, but to be honest for $25, I was quite disappointed. Both of these sandwiches should be easy to make much better, and I hope they take this critique seriously and improve the caliber. Orillia needs good little restaurants and I hope they can improve and survive.

Sarah Johnstone

Best Cannoli Ive had since I was a child and nana made them for me. Marinara sauce tasted just like my families homemade recipe. Excellent

David Coleman

The best place in Orillia if your looking for ice cream. .... what’s even better all the Italian items they carry. The owner is very friendly ... support your local businesses !!! Will be back for their new flavours next week

Lee Bowman

Excellent service however the lunch was okay at best and extremely overpriced. $70 for 3 sandwiches olives and 2 Gelatos. Will go back for the Gelato only.

prit patel

Great sandwiches and gelato. Can’t wait to come back!