Reviews of Fair Catch Fishmongers (Fish Shop)

Gary C

Geneviève and Rob are super friendly and knowledgeable. Bought some pasta neck clams and a whole rainbow trout. Mentioned I was walking around the neighborhood for lunch and Rob offered a bag of ice which was a nice touch.

Adam Shaw

I stopped by the store for the first time today, and was very impressed with the exceptional service and cleanliness. The owners seem committed to providing top shelf products, and glad I was able to find a local shop so close to home.

Marc Carvalho

I told them I wanted to make gravlax and instead of giving the piece on display, they got me a piece of salmon better suited for gravlax from the back. It turned out amazing and I believe a lot of that had to do with the quality of the fish. It's great to support a local business and even better when they sell a quality product.

Lawrence Wallach

Great steamed lobster. Great smoked trout. Looking forward to trying more things.

Melanie Patterson

Freshest oysters we ever had! We’ve tried many places around Toronto! Super impressed with the food and service! We will be back for more!

Craig Omundsen

Superb selection of top of the range quality seafood and seafood-centric grocery items. My wife and I find the people working there to be very knowledgeable and fair - just like the name. Huge thanks to the team for your contribution to top quality tastiness.

Marc Knez

What a find!! GREAT fish, GREAT service, GREAT location, beautiful store...highly recommend to anyone with a discerning palate.

Soyeon Park

I got small clams for pasta yesterday They were so fresh I’ll go back again!

kyra li

Incredible pre-made chowder! Amazing for busy weeknight meals.

Kathy Leeder

Found this gem in our neighbourhood yesterday and so happy we did! Mother’s Day lunch started off with caviar and Arctic char, followed by a couple of trays of mixed oysters and ended with fish cakes. Everything was delicious. The service was fantastic, product knowledge was great and the choice made our stay at home Mother’s Day the best ever. Thank you and see you again soon.

Manny Serpa

Delicious! A great experience overall.

L Martinez

We installed some window graphics for Fair Catch Fishmongers. Very friendly team!

Sina Akhlaghizadeh

Went there for the first time and I was blown away by the amazing quality of the fish. Ended up getting some pickerel and it was just incredible. Will definitely go back!

Fiona Press

So amazing to have a real fish/seafood store in the area! - the oysters and Pickerel was so fresh and delicious ????!!

L Monteith

So happy to have a seafood store in the neighborhood. I ordered black cod to make the famous Nobu black cod and miso. Did not disappoint. The cod was amazing. Fresh and delicious. Will be back for the ahi tuna!

Jimmy Yau

So glad this store opened up in our neighbourhood. My wife and I have been here a few times and the fish is always really fresh, much better than what you'd find at your local grocery store. Their oysters are also really good, we called ahead of time and they helped us shuck them when we picked up. The owner is also friendly and helpful. We will definitely be going back soon.

Sue From Toronto

Fabulous selection and service. I am now an Arctic char fan. Everyone loved it! No leftovers, tho

Sam Sabarinath

I bought Sea bass from this place and it was super fresh ! I'll definitely go back here and will recommend to friends and family. Very clean and well maintained.

George Skok

Read about this shop in the North Toronto Post and was glad to learn there was a seafood place in our area!!! I pre-ordered oysters and they were ready when I came. Delicious! I picked up some terrific cod as well, and we enjoyed a wonderful family dinner. The owners are corteous, the store is impeccably clean, and the experience was very satisfying. We'll be back for sure!!!