Reviews of Evelyn's Sandwich Factory (Bakery)

Little Jim

Hey everyone, out for a short drive and needed some fuel for both the car and family (not in that order) so stopped into this great clean place in Welland. Some serious sandwiches in here that were not only sooo Fresh but super tasty with any add on you want. Although not a big sandwich chap, must say that those sandwiches could change me over. Try out the Garlic Noodle soup too and the hefty roast turkey sandwich - Two Winners in my book Oh yes, did also get some gas...almost forgot after such a memorable meal..... GO RAPS!!!!!

Courtney M

Very good!

Tammy Lavigne

Best homemade sandwiches and soups in town. Great to support small business

Seika Groves

Delicious sandwiches.. pastrami today!

Stephanie Siemens

Evelyn you make a great sandwich!

The Creative Mommy

First time going in today to grab lunch for hubby and I and both our sandwiches and sides were delicious! I can't wait to go back ❤

Matthew Craggs

These sandwiches are amazing. Fresh ingredients, friendly staff, nice quaint atmosphere. Do yourself a favour and visit this place.

Justin Reichelt

Amazing lunch. Real homemade roast beef and roasted turkey on fresh bakery buns. You can't go wrong

Capt. John Swallow

Best sandwiches in the region! Design your own, deli style, loads of options, always delicious! Pyrate Approved ™

Emmalise Corrine

I'm 24 years of age and I was born and raised in Welland. For some reason I never went to Evelyn's sandwich shop. Today I wandered in... hungry and looking for a delicious meal. Well that's exactly what I got and so much more! The experience was amazing! I feel like I need to make up for the 18 years ( how long the shop has been open ) and eat there a hell of alot more! It was fresh, delicious, inviting and the vibe was a very warm, welcoming feeling. 100% recommended to anyone who has yet to visit this adorable location!

Cedric C

The sandwiches here are probably the best you’ll ever have, no matter what you pick. Amazing variety, ingredients are always super fresh, and the customer service just makes you feel all warm and fuzzy inside like they are really taking care of you. Excellent spot, must try in Niagara for sure.

Trena

Was in the area and went for lunch with the kids. Had a turkey sandwhich and it was amazing.. not the sliced turkey breast you get at most places, it was turkey like you'd use to make sandwiches after making thanksgiving dinner. And they were amazing enough to grill up a cheese sandwhich for my kids to share. Will definitely come back when we're in the area.

D P

Love their sandwiches! Such fresh high quality ingredients. I always get the turkey breast one. Evelyn and Pam are awesome and being new to the area, they make you feel right at home :) Thanks ladies!

Tyler Rollo

Really amazing thick & meatwich MUST GOO

Chris Bowman

The only thing I could ever say negative about this incredible stop is the hours, and that is unfair to them since I now work out of town when they are open. This place is incredible; fresh bread from across the street, fresh ingredients, homemade soups, the list goes on. If you haven't been, you are truly missing out on the best gourmet sandwich stop in Niagara.

Greg Owen

The best sandwich anywhere ⭐⭐⭐⭐

Amanda Frado

Hands down best sandwich I've ever had. Made to order from fresh ingredients! Owner is a sweetheart as well :)

Eddie Wright

Best soups and sandwiches in town

Brian Stanicki

Great soup and sandwiches. Perfect little lunch spot.

Hannah Eve

Best place for lunch!! Love it so much ❤️❤️

Lindsey Drover

Very cute little place,friendly staff and the sandwiches are tasty and you get plenty on 'em. Will go back.

Mario Di Giovanni

Top notch sandwiches.

Brock Morden

❤️

Aaron Whitaker

Best soup and sandwiches by far. Different soups made fresh daily and a different special every Wednesday. Well worth the stop if you have never been.

sodapopinskiii84

Best sandwich shop I have ever been to, and I have been to plenty.

Josh Allan

Best quality sandwiches in the city. Even though there were 8 people ahead of me, it was still a very reasonable wait for my food. Very fast and very delicious!

larsonny77

This place is absolutely amazing, it has a home feel as you walk in. There is a card which you fill out with bread, toppings meats ect and you have tons of options! The sandwich is pure bliss, really turkey and meats, fresh vegetables and the best bread. The only down side is they only take cash but that's how she keeps her prices so low! So no complaints there a large sandwich with tax under $10 you can't beat that.

BadHairGaming

The absolute, 100% best sandwich place in the city! Great food and service!

Kenzie Hall

Meal type

Pauline Blondeau

too much tuna salad on sandwich. Was very messy and difficult to eat.

Kount Kreepy

Great sandwiches! Good size for your dollar!

Ahad Med

Omg ! I love thier sandwiches! They make the best sandwiches in town .big like !

Linda

They do have delicious sandwiches however I have been 3 times and they have yet to get my order correct with toppings. The last time I went, they actually gave me 2 cups of soup with bread and 1 sandwich but I ordered 2 sandwiches and 1 bowl of soup. I wasn't going to bother taking it back but my bf insisted on calling them. I actually started eating the soup and then they asked us to bring everything back so they could get us the right order....they took the partially eaten soup back and put it aside as it was someone else's order but they didn't want to remake the hot sandwich knowing it would obviously be soggy by the time we drove back there and then back home....well even without covid, they should have just said to keep the soups as I had brought them home and everything. Hope that customer was okay with their bread having a bite out of it. Love the food but can't go back and Def don't want to after they actually wanted the food back. Gross!

Toronto Fishing

Amazing sandwiches ????

M

I was super excited to try this place out but was rather disappointed. For the price, I was disappointed with the quantity and quality of the sandwich. It was super messy to eat and difficult to hold. The gravy was really salty and hard to enjoy. They also messed up my boyfriend's order. Hoping this was a one-off experience but I will not be returning unfortunately.

Anna Chicory

One of the friendliest places I've been in a long time! Sandwiches are delicious and fresh! Thank you!

Gary Johnston

Large sandwich is a real meal, I found the regular size plenty for lunch. Lots of choices very fresh and delicious. They don't seem to take debit but have a ATM in the establishment , but it will ding you for a 2 dollar service fee, so add that to the price of your meal and it is fairly expensive. So make sure you have cash in hand.

Jacob Falardeau

Best place to stop for lunch in town. Great sandwiches for a great price.

Stacey Carr

Delicious, affordable friendly staff. Loved it!

Christopher M

Friendly service, good food.

Lisa Allain

Myself and staff are right around the corner from this shop. We often get our lunches here. The service is incredible and the food. Oh my. From the bread to the filler it is something you have got to try. The value you get for your dollar is outstanding. We are very happy clients.

Nathalie Bilodeau

Always fresh and homemade. The perfect sandwich shop if you ask me. You get to customize everything just the way you like it. Service is always so friendly and welcoming, whether you're a regular or a new face. And the soups!!

Mike Delaney

Amazing service! Was greeted warmly the minute I entered the store being a first timer in the store I was explained how the ordering system worked. After I had placed my order I was offered to take a seat and that they would bring my order to me. The food was amazing! I ordered a Pastrami sandwich (regular size) with a coke. I managed to finish the portion but barely! Price wise you will be hard pressed to find this quality sandwich and service anywhere else in the area!

Shellene Taylor

Omg yummy. Good value fresh food

Chris Filipowicz

Great sandwiches and soup

sharon stewart

great a t as always

Maggie Aronoff

Mmmm... so tasty and lovely serves too.

Tania VanAlstine

(Translated) Name.name name (Original) Nom.nom nom

beatrice fink

friendly and great service the food is amazing love the garlic noodle soup.

Trav Mane

A1 Customizer sandwich shop in town, hands down.

Nathan

Super fresh sandwiches that will fill you up all day.

Rachel Stoykovich

Love this place, never have had a bad sandwich and always have had lovely service. ❤️

Chawna Wells

I absolutely love it here. Soup or a sandwich always so delicious and always leave happy. Evelyn's has always been so great to me and they're always so friendly.

Lorraine Wentz

ALWAYS amazing sammies!!! Meatball sub was deliciously messy! The way it should be!

Shane Leedham

Friendly service, great sandwiches

Stitch 308

WOWY! This is a sandwich! I love food, I am very picky and love the classics. This is an amazing Turkey Sammy on wicked fresh bread and alllll the garnish anyone could ever want. Caught them just before closing. Pam and Nikita were gracious enough to make me lunch. I have been waiting far to long to try this place out. If you havent, go to Evelyn's ASAP! Have a nice turkey or roast beef! Tell em I sent ya! Thanks again! Xo

Jacqueline Speck

Evelyn's is wonderful. Another great local business to support. The quality and care that goes into each sandwich is impeccable. You get a card with meats breads and toppings and you check off what you would like. Fun stuff! It's pretty small only about two or three tables so don't expect to have a group of more than four if you want to eat in. I feel sad if you have not experienced Evelyn's

cheryl hodgkins

I bought 3 large chicken vegetable soups. I ended up giving my soups away because they were quite bland, way too peppery and noodles were put in the soup after i was told they wouldnt be.

Chad Scully

By Far the best sandwich shop in Welland! House cooked soups and meats that make any sandwich awesome. Been going for years and will continue.

Andre D

Best F#@$ing sandwich i've ever had in my life, Evelyn is a goddess!

Fezal Ackburally

My usual go to place for lunch here in Welland

Justin Dafoe

Best sandwich place in Welland...I mean Niagara...best sandwich place EVERRRR!!!

Dylan Mask

The BEST soup and sandwiches this side of the Mississippi... actually ever.

Garry Boyd

Excellant food and variety. Soup is very good and changes daily. The variety and selections of sandwich combinations is unlimited. Think if it and they will make it. A highly recommended shop with an interesting atmosphere and friendly staff

Blood Sweat And Tears Forever learning

Good people

Justin Bryan

Super clean and relaxing

Derek Stonier

Love this place. Soooo Good

Alyssa Klassen

Simply amazing! Like the daily special Facebook posts

Roxy Nicole

So Delicious, absolutely love their fresh selections of meat and veggies , variety of cheese, the menu's you fill out are so customer friendly it makes ordering your perfect combos of choices easy. Today I couldn't help but order the chicken salad, with dill pickles, lettuce , mozzarella and cheddar, with some regular mustard, all on a fresh Calabrese bun , so yummy, I got a regular and I'm stuffed, the quality of food is just as good as the awesome staff, makes going there enjoyable each time. Check it out! You won't be disappointed.

Derek Galipeau

Excellent!

Dee S

Fresh homemade sandwiches and soups. Generous portions. Always greeted with smiles.

alie Joanis

Love coming here.! Great food. Great price. Always fresh. And the treats made are delicious!

P. Sodtka

Hands down best sandwiches around! I absultuly love their food so fresh and delicious! I highly recommend you give it a try.

Nancy Duff

Great food, great service. tons of options. Quaint little place. Will definitly go back and recommend it to my friends and family.

Deryk Viger

Awesome all around. Great service, great food, local.

Colin Kennie

Delicious sandwiches, nice small town feel, fresh ingredients!

Rudy Gerling

The sandwich was amazing. The in store roasted turkey and the thick Vienna bread was just moist enough to contain the enormous stack of fillings. My only real regret was my own choice failure. Instead of the sub sauce, I should have gone with mayo.

Sunaina Saxena

Broke our Evelyn's v-card today and it was well worth it. We are still pretty new to this area and when driving by this spot, it was always after hours, and we always said we wanted to check it out. Today was our lucky day!!! We had the pleasure of meeting Evelyn who was very welcoming. As fellow local business owners, we truly appreciate this gem you've created. As we entered the shop, we were immediately drawn to the get up. All the antiques stood out and were quite fitting. The menu is appealing and we grabbed sandwiches today. Completely blown away by all of the variety of toppings that we could choose from. We are impressed that just like us, she makes everything with fresh produce, etc. This makes us happy. I also like the idea of customers filling out the order sheet themselves. Totally worth every penny and we will be back often, we know that for sure! Sandwich was delicious and I cannot wait to try more from the menu!!!

Freakshow2599

Customize your own delicious sandwhich, great soups of the day. The quality is so much better than Subway yet costs the same.

Collin Marchand

For anybody with wheat allergies/intolerance, lettuce wraps are available in lieu of bread. I got the regular size and was very full afterwards. Food tasted fresh and yummy, staff was friendly, price reasonable and service was quick. No complaints here!

Arthur Gostick

Hard to beat. You pick the ingredients and they make you a custom sandwich with really fresh ingredients.

Carleen LeBlanc

This is a REAL sandwich. Soft bread, fresh lettuce, great toppings. The reviews speak for themselves. It's easy to pass by this place as it's been here so long, but if you've never been, please go! You won't regret it.

Brenda Frame

This is our favourite sandwich place, freshly made sandwiches with home made soup. Love it.

C D

Great sandwhiches and lovely people.

Ella RoseDay Marten

Delicious!

Alex 143

Oh boy, only the tastiest "handmade with love" sandwiches. Evelyn's got a perfect sandwich menu, and everything is made fresh with fresh ingredients.

Kitty Brown

Love the fresh turkey sandwich. I have been ordering Evelyn's Sandwiches for years and never disappointed <3

Jess Hamilton

Amazing food! Always fresh. Expect a bit of a wait, but well worth it!

Kat Dupuis

The best sandwiches I've ever eaten. Anyone that has never been here I highly recommend it

Faith Garner

Good food, friendly service, clean

Sarah McNary

It is my favourite sandwich place around. Very homey and very good food.

Pete Meszaros

Sammiches are incredible????

Gordon Muscroft

Great little local sandwich shop. This is great everyday food not gourmet gluten free. Just good food. Will return when in the area.

Dez B

Will only be ordering from Evelyn's! Tasty sandwiches made in a clean environment! Very well trusted ???? Fresh ingredients and excellent prices!! Make your orders now!

Brenda Searight

This little gem has the best sandwiches in town! I wish they had more than one location. Their turkey sandwiches are delicious!

Mike Dobsi

Great little sandwich spot in an unassuming location. This place is cash only, so be sure to have some on you. If not, there's an onsite ATM. There are only a couple tables to eat, so it's best to take it to go. Walk in, grab a pencil and the ordering paper and create your dream sandwich. Only recommendation I have is that I wish they had pre-selected sandwich ideas for you

Daniel Yates

Always awesome!

Purple Pickle

Salami with chicken salad?? Yess!! I had the best sandwich of my life today here. I’ll be back for sure.

HK

Another great local gem. Sandwiches are always fresh and leave you feeling satisfied. Nothing better than picking up some sandwiches from Evelyn’s to take with you to a party or picnic!

ryan lustri

Lunch

J Pruden

Amazing hand made sandwiches, loaded with everything you want. Soup and sandwich combos. Amazing selection of bread, a true gem in Welland. A go to for lunch

Michael Bedard

Always great . Always a wonderful experience.

Aaron Motchka

Amazing fresh sandwiches. Fantastic homemade soups

Parvis Sasani

Delicious, big sandwiches. Bread is amazing & homemade! I got the turkey sandwich and it was not deli turkey, it was good quality, roasted turkey. Cash only so make sure you bring cash!

Andrew Lee

Simply put....you will not be disappointed.

Conrad Seymour

Good sandwich by suggestions from owner. Fresh products served on a soft kaiser bun, all for under $10

Margo C

Best sandwich deli spot in Niagara Region.

Todd Dixon

I love this place so friendly always remembers my name and the food is fresh and awesome. Great job Thank you

Michael Currie

Great sandwiches the way you like them.

Joe Gonzalez

Have never had anything here short of amazing! Fresh ingredients and hot, delicious soup!

Head Banger666

So fresh and the variety is amazing!

Penny Smith

We have to drive half an hour to this place, the sandwiches are so good they are worth the drive.. their soups are kinda plain but the sandwiches are awesome

Kevin Pietz

My wife's favorite place, fresh made to order sandwiches, the best ingredients, when you order roast beef, you get REAL beef from a roast she cooked and sliced. Not the presliced from the grochery store deli, the same goes with the turkey. Great place!

Markus Kompp

Great home made sandwiches

Mike Sullivan

Sandwiches and soups are fantastic!! Very friendly staff!

Carly D

Always very fresh ingredients and friendly service, will continue to visit!

Jr Phillip

Evelyn, her daughter and athe other female team member are the world! Their sandwiches are the death of me literally. I found out about this place a month before covid and was devastated by their closure for covid. They are now open again however. I would reccomend these gourmet sandwiches to anyone. They take cash only. They got a massive parking spot. Their decor in their little cozy shop is beautiful and homey.

Fraser Howard

Best pulled-pork sandwich with coleslaw and garlic mayonnaise on a Kaiser you will ever have. Real friendly service too!

T R

Good sandwiches. They were out of turkey when I ordered, & they didnt get my order right. They put lettuce instead of sprouts, light rye instead of dark& ended up giving me turkey instead of chicken salad. If I knew I was getting turkey, I would have adjusted my toppings instead of thinking I was getting chicken salad. Over all, the sandwich was still good & prices werent bad at all. Turkey was delicious.

Mike Irwin

Best sandwiches around!

Ashley Secord

Great food and people

Ram Welland Lead Hand

Hands down the Best place to get soups and sandwiches. The lovely ladies there are awesome as well!

Michael Kutlesa

A really quaint, unique setting. Barely any seating, but it's a fantastic place to hit up for a quick-ish lunch. If they're not too busy, the service is fast, and it's always friendly. Great value in my opinion, especially from such a little place.

H Ferreira

No. 1 Sandwiches

JessieLynn l

Stopped in today for lunch, the soup of the day was borscht. As good as it looks and smells, it tastes even better. Some fresh bread on the side and it was the perfect meal for such a drab day.

Doug Whalley

This place is great highly recommend it

Bob Mallen

Best sandwich shop I've ever stopped at (and I drive a lot for my job). Best if you aim for lunch, as their stuff is fresh daily so they may run out of some stuff by end of day. Will be back as often as possible!

John

Great find! Stopped here while driving through Welland. Super good sandwich and really friendly staff. Not your usual sandwich place. Tons of options to create different combinations. Also very reasonable prices. Would highly recommend.

Rebecca Little

Fresh and never disappoints!

Melissa Metcalfe

Take out

zacksteele128

Went in this past week. Ordered 2 sandwiches. Places is small, homely. Ordering system is pretty basic. Selection is small, however its more about getting to the point then taking an hour to decide. Some of the meat is produced in house which is nice !! Prices arent to shabby for food that isnt deep fried etc. Many healthy options for your meal. You eat first, pay later. I will be going back, staff are friendly, food is good.!! EDIT. Also...bring CASH!

Doug Zack

Beef vegetable soup and Meatloaf sandwich were the special. Both extremely good. The ladies behind the counter were very friendly.

Ryan Lilley

Fantastic sandwiches and soup!

Alex Ng

Fresh sandwiches with plenty of options, and the soup was delicious.

Dan Swords

The best

Rick Radz

I just had one of the most incredible sandwiches made by one of the nicest ladies in Welland...and not just any sandwich...this is the sandwich you make before the football game on Sunday when you're cleaning up the leftovers after a major holiday...stacked high and absolutely delicious! Thanks!

Amy Simpson (Mimi)

Amazing food! Always fresh and very generous portions. I am never disappointed with the food here. Best sandwiches EVER!

Ivan Ostric

Great food and service!

D Ricard

(Translated) Yummmmmmmmmmmmy (Original) Yummmmmmmmmmmmy

Mel H

This place knows how to make a great sandwich. I'm so happy I discovered Evelyn's Sandwich Factory. The staff are so friendly. They use fresh ingredients. They roast a turkey everyday so it's not deli slices. Goodbye Subway! She told me I would be back and she was right. She's either psychic or she has full confidence in her food. I believe it's the latter. Try Evelyn's sandwiches. You won't be disappointed.

Millennium Computers

Awesome food.

Serge Daoust

Great place to pick up a fresh sandwich and homemade soup

Ben Derisgreat

Food was good but $12 for a large sandwich an pop is ridiculous

Gert Meijer

Great food!! Heard about it. They were right! Awesome.

Ljs Roti Shop

Evelyn's offers the best customer service of all time. The ladies are super awesome! These sandwiches are super gourmet and delicious.

dan cook

Great food and service

brian steinhoff

Great quality and friendly service with amazing protions and prices

Josh

Placed an order then was forced to wait 45 minutes, and watch people get served that ordered long after I did so I could pay overpay for a very mediocre sandwich that should have taken 5 minutes. One of the staff ladies actually gave me attitude when I voiced the extended wait time that "it will take 5 or 10 minutes to make an order" not realizing I had been waiting close to 40 minutes at that time. Even if the sandwiches were something special, (they are not) I wouldn't go back due to the terrible service.

Scott Moore

I love this place. Get exactly what you want. Type of meat,cheese, all the garnishes and choice of bread.

Ruff LIfe

Fabulous sandwich, good value, convenient and quality ingredients! Bravo

Dan Dostie

Awesome sandwiches and soup

Kim Silvio

Best Sammich Ever!!

JL Frado

This place is wonderful. The service is outstanding, the people kind and the quality of food is top notch. Definitely worth a stop!

Angelo Melaragni

Nice selection of sandwiches and soup. Reasonable prices. Mostly a lunch nook. Limited sit-in tables.

Mel Cola

Best sandwiches!

TheDragoon989

Grabbed my first sandwich from here today and it was so good, only thing mildly inconvenient is they only take cash but that's really the only thing that could be improved.

Brady Johnston

Never before has a sandwich brought a tear to my eye like this one, paired it with a great split pea and ham soup. This place is a great little spot and the prices are very reasonable.

Chris Mccammon

Fantastic sandwiches, great people!

Dustin Swords

Best sandwiches period, the bread is fantastic, & the staff is always friendly

rick wilsher

Amazing

Shawn Abbs

Fantastic food and service I should have tried a long time ago

Jason Porter

Wow! Fantastic sandwich.

Kelly Sault

Would recommend Evelyn's to anyone. Food is awesome. Reasonable prices.

Jacob Cashin

My favourite lunch spot in Welland! Sandwiches are always made with fresh ingredients, and the staff are always friendly.

David DiPietro

Incredible, authentic sandwiches. You won't find a better sandwich in the Niagara region, I guarantee it. It's always a pleasure going in here for lunch and being warmly greeted. The lunch meats are so fresh and all of the ingredients are always top notch. Even if you're not in Welland, it's worth the drive.

judy white

Lovely place. Friendly, helpful staff.

Sam Smith

Fabulous sandwiches and soups. Guaranteed to be fresh and delicious.

Alexander Lapere

Awesome sandwich

Josh Hadwen

Great sandwiches, customize your own with a good little selection of meat, bread, and veggies served by the friendliest ladies. 10/10 Will eat here again.

Heather Baker

Always delicious, and fresh. Worth every single penny, you won’t get a better bang for your buck anywhere else. Always the best customer service. Love you ladies ! ????

Keith Hamilton

Service

Lise Chabot

Delicious soups and sandwiches every time!!

maureen flaherty

Clean, Good quality meats, Fresh veggies, good selection of breads and condiments. Evelyn is a very friendly professional business lady. Service with a ????.

Cathy Rooker

Great food very nice staff

Adam Rinker

Really fresh and delicious sandwiches. Many different options. Had the roast turkey. Which was real roast turkey, not deli meat. For the regular size, I struggled to finish it. Best sandwich shop in Welland.

Steph Mercier

Best sandwiches in town! A+

Shonah Laurenti

Amazing soup! Fabulous sandwich made to order!! Definitely be back!

Kristin Williams

I have always wanted to stop and just haven't. Today i did and am i ever glad i did! I love the menu! The sandwich was HUGE and so good. Service was fantastic! I WILL be eating here again!!! Soon!!!

Adam

I love going here, great sandwiches at great prices with lots of selections!

Roseanna Gucciardi

Went there Friday for the first time. I'm gluten free so l knew it might not be possible to get anything. Once l talked to the staff they assured me that they could make me any sandwich with lettuce like a wrap if l wanted or a salad. I chose a julian salad with their home made balsamic dressing. It was delicious l highly recommend this establishment. I will be going back for sure.