Reviews of Itty Bitty Pie Company (Bakery)

Kimberley Thompson

We tried the country chicken pie, chicken curry pie and keto Turkey pie. ALL delicious and would buy again!

Nora Mclellan

Great Soups and Pies!

Vic Mueller

First time here. Pies and pastries are good.

Sriti M

Great tiny pies and keto food. Makes it easy to plan meals. Good location.

dan

When we went we got the tiramisu, a few pastries and a container of frozen soup. The tiramisu was the most moist cake I've ever had in my life, I heated up about 1/2 of the soup and then made the rest right after because it was so good, and the pastries were also great (I think we got a few cheesecakes, and others I'm forgetting because we ate them so quickly).

Naval Shah

We've only tried the sweet (either fruit or cream based) pies but have been incredibly happy with everything we've ordered. Our family's favourites (in no particular order) are the lemon meringue, apple cranberry, key lime, and the coconut cream. We've never been disappointed with picking up an assortment of the mini pies, and I highly recommend picking up a few next time you're in the area.

Keylee

I ordered a banana cream pie from them last week for my boyfriend's birthday and he absolutely loved it and so did I. Will be ordering from them again

Rui Yin

We tried the apple crumble pie and it’s so delicious, we will be back for more.

Savy Techgirl

Great selection of pies! You can also find them at local farmers markets!

Gary Goemans

I ordered a bunch of desserts for a family party, and I must say I was personally over the moon with the butter tarts with raisins! The best I've ever had, the flavours burst in my mouth. I also have to say the Cherry Pie and Mississippi mud pie were a huge hit with everybody that was there, everybody's taste buds were intoxicated with joy. Thank you so much, I will definitely be a returning customer!

Sarah Kellaway

Their pastry is amazing

Cassy Carpino

We ordered mini pies for dessert at our wedding and they were a hit! People loves the variety of flavours, how cute they looked and of course how delicious they were. Pam was extremely flexible with planning around our covid wedding.

Kate Gottli

I have only had the sweet/dessert pies from there but they were FAB. the sampler pack was fantastic, definitely recommend!

Paul Heron

I only found this place because I was meeting a friend next door for lunch. I’m batching it this week, so decided to get a small meat pie for dinner. Glad I did! I asked the proprietor which pie she was most proud of, and she said, “Chipotle Beef.” Fabulous!! Lovely blend of flavors and the right amount of heat. I’ll be back to try the others.

Alyssa Boldt-Peacock

Amazing pies and very friendly staff! We used Itty Bitty Pies for our wedding in October 2019 and the pies on a stick as well as the mini take home pies were a huge success! We absolutely love how many vegan options they have. My favourites are the vegan Jamaican patty and the pesto veggie. It’s also great to know that all of their fruit pies are vegan as well! I would recommend them to anyone!

Leslie Smith

Great food, great service and prices can't be beat.

Darrell Mason

Got mixer of 6 itty bitty pies and every single one was amazing! And super friendly staff too! ????

Astrid Galfi

We worked with Pam for our wedding and it was an absolute hit! The pies were so delicious, so incredibly special and we're so glad we worked with the Itty Bitty Pie Co. for our wedding

Kimberly Bosson

I found this place rather disappointing and not worth the price. We got two strawberry cheesecake cups that just weren't sweet enough, and a mini peanut butter pie which had the same issue. It just tastes like peanut butter and cream cheese mixed together and that's it. Ultimately, it really wasn't what we were looking for. The presentation was nice and the second star is for that.

Todd Ostaszewicz

Awesome pies, friendly owners.

Lori Dobson

My husband was craving pie! I searched google for the best pie in the Niagara region. Itty bitty pie was on the top 3. So... We stopped by and I grabbed a frozen apple pie. Got home and baked it "followed instructions on the bag". It turned out to be the best apple pie we have ever had "all 5 of my kids also agree". Not too sweet. Perfect amount of cinnamon. Delish! We will be back for more!! Keep up the good work!!

John-Paul Cote

Itty Bitty Pies is awesome. Nuff said.

Toasty Bagel

Amazing Pies!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! =^..^= *meow*

Penny Gardiner

Love, love, love their pies

Dar

Got gift certificate, absolutly love this place, very kind service,awesome crust going back very soon.

Debbie Bird

Very tasty sweet pies. Lemon was my favourite!

Bradley Ryan

Great place to grab some delicious pies!

John Min

Drove from Welland on 9.28 to check this place out, but was closed. Thanks! *Update* appreciate the offer but not sure when i will be in st catharines again. Upgraded to 3 stars for reply.

Get Money

Love this place great pies!!!!

Mark James

Wonderful keto fresh made treats!

Krista Revelle-Levy

I have only been once and would go back. Bought a couple of pies and they were very good. Plan on going back to buy more of there chicken pot pie. I have to say I have been back many times since. The staff are amazing and is only topped by the amazing food you receive..... Come hungry leave full

Kieran Scott

Was thrilled to be able to order a key lime pie for my friend's 60th birthday! Made the request online and Pam the owner called me to confirm my order. The pie was delicious, creamy and light. Happy to support such a lovely local business.

Dan Biggar

Great pies and other frozen foods for ready to eat

Kristina Elkins

Who knew pies could be SO GOOD. A friend and i just stopped in because we saw it driving down the road, turned out to be (by far) the best food we ate on our trip. We got the country chicken and holiday turkey from reccomendation and she was right. Just spectacular, i have been dreaming about coming back here. You can tell the ingredients are top quality and fresh and the baker really knows how to work with flavors and textures. It was so moist but not mushy and so flavorful for such simple ingredients. It was nice they had tons of vegan options too. I dont live close to here but man do i want to come back.

G3 Designs Photo and Video

OMG if you haven't had a pie from itty bitty pie you are missing alot great company and awesome customer service p.s you have to try the meat pies

Marko Coso

Best pies ever!

Robert Dickinson

Stunningly good pies! The place is super cute and family owned, but wow the pies really steal the show. Country chicken and holiday turkey were good enough to warrant the 10 hour trip back. I live nowhere near here - but will be coming back at some point.

Amy Whittaker

Coconut Pie was to die for! Excellent service, Pie lady played with my son while I was reading selection. She even gave my son a free Pie. I highly recommend trying Itty Bitty Pies!

Nick Cherniak

Got a apple pie for Thanksgiving. First time customer. In my opinion the crust is dry. It's not flakey and there's no egg wash on top to give it color. The filling was very good and liked the shape of the pie was unique. The pies are on the more expensive side so I was a little disappointed with crust overall

Vito Pennimpede

Awesome pies!

dooee222

Amazing ! Delicious !

Sexy Ma

I loved all the vegan meat pies I've tried. Very reasonably priced. She also makes the best butter pecan tarts ever!

Corey Canham

Staff was very nice. Pies were delicious

David Torres

It is an absolute must stop by place in St. Catharines! For a few weeks now my friends and girlfriend have been wanting to go in and try their pies. Recently , I have gone in and bought one of each of their vegan pies to try and see how they are and I am not saying I am but religious ...LORD they are amazing! I can't say enough but GO GO GO! You won't regret it! There are great options for vegans and meat lovers alike!

Vera Berezuk

Absolutely the best pie crust I've ever had. Bought the key lime, lemon meringue, & PB tarts & can't get over how amazing the crusts are!! Fillings were luscious, delicious & decadent but WOW those crusts!!

Steve Foster

place is awsome, keto options are good, pies are the best

Jess Little

Absolutely love the Buffalo Chicken meat pies, they were all delicious and made to perfection, thank you !

Elwin Anthonypillai

Love the pies! There is so much variety and everything is delicious. The people working are super nice and helpful. Awesome experience and will definitely be going back! The Buffalo chicken pot pie is too good!

K P

Must try their butter tarts ???????? absolutely divine!! Their pumpkin cheesecake is also delicious!

Jennifer Robertson

Great little shop, ladies are very helpful and kind Mini pies were very delicious!!

Dee Polson

Great pies, nice people!

Taryn Laine

The staff is delightful at Itty Bitty! And the pies…oh the pies! The seasonal mini Turkey Dinner is one of my favourites. It is so good! I also cannot go in without grabbing the mini Coconut Cream and Peanut Butter Cream pies. Talk about heaven in a tart shell! ????????

Karen S

I highly recommend the Itty Bitty Pie Company. Their pies and tarts are so delicious! They offer a great selection of pies made from fresh fruit in the Niagara area. The pastry combined with the local fruit make their pies especially good. There are also savoury gourmet pies which also look and sound delicious. I will deffinately be back.

david shen

very nice

Andrea J

Found a bug baked into a tart (makes me sick just thinking about it). Owner is very childish and unprofessional. Definitely will not return!

Alex Dionne

Absolutely amazing! Must try, super fresh and easy reheating process. Amazing customer service as well!

Gemma Copland

Best little gem in Niagara, thank you

citizenmars78

Oh my god I love this place although disappointed in myself for using that phrase. Love it, love it, love it. A bit pricey but soooo worth it. Great selection and is a definite treat. One pie won’t fill you up but two will leave you stuffed. Great to have in the freezer for those I don’t want to cook but need something good and healthy in the freezer. Go and try them. You’re welcome

Jen Davidson

Great local business to support! Our whole family loves the variety of individual pot pies and are excited to see which ones I bring home!

Julie D

Walked out with 4 pies, a strawberry rhubarb pie, and a lemon meringue in a cup. Had 2 bites of the lemon meringue and went back into the store to buy 3 more plus try out the other flavors: oreo, peanutbutter and jam, and strawberry. All so so good!

Tara Mallett

Love the food love the service!!! The options are endless:)

Xanthe C

Always fun to visit! The food is delicious and well made. Keep doing what youre doing!

john levick

Great pies whether sweet or savoury!

Kevin Burger

Never had a bad item from them

Abdi Abdi

Itty bitty pie made me love pies more then I ever did...I eat for breakfast lunch and dinner sometimes...love ????????

Sarah Dion

Amazing pies. We got and apple pie and a mixed berry crumble for Thanksgiving weekend. Both were some of the best pies I've ever had. The crust is so flaky and thick. I like buying them frozen and then cooking at home.

fort scolaro

Great prices

Craig Logan

Simply outstanding is all I can say!!

MiMi Rivait

Great atmosphere great options

Lynn Shaver

A gift box of pastry brought to us by our kids for our anniversary and they are almost sinful. So lite and delicious we will make a stop ourselves. What a treat, Thankyou!!!!

Nick

Just had a wonderful, delicious feta and spinach quiche from the Itty BItty Pie Company. Wish I'd known about them sooner. I'm sure I'll be back before long, and I know I've got my vegan sister interested.

Meaghan Clayton

Itty Bitty Pie is to die for! The pies are the perfect size and jam packed with flavour! If you're looking for the perfect dessert these are for you! They even have the most delicious savoury pies ! Can't go wrong with pie!

Kevin Hubbs

I just can't say enough good things about this little gem of a business. Warm, friendly greeting when you walk in. Very clean store. Addictive pies! I'm hooked on the Holiday Turkey (my absolute favourite) and Chipotle Beef (picture spicy beef stew topped with delicious cornbread!) but there are many savoury pies to choose from and I haven't tried one yet that I haven't liked. I try to stay away from the sweet stuff but it's pretty well impossible to walk out of that place without at least one Mississippi Mud mini coming with me. So many creative sweet or savoury pies to choose from that you'll find something for every palate, every craving, every mood. Love this place!

Lynn Enns

Purchased from Itty Bity Pie for a meeting. Everyone raved about how delicious and fresh everything was. The apple crumble pie was still warm when I picked my order up! Awesome service as well.