Reviews of Mama Misfit's Cheesecakery (Bakery)

Real Talkz

If you don't like mama misfits you have no soul or don't like cheesecake which means you're irrelevant to me anyway

Ramazan Halit Acar

rude staff

Courtney M

Delicious but overpriced.

Carol Isaac

So good!

Ignat Ospadov

Delicious

Shams AbuBakr

Very nice cheese cakes. ???? loved it

Elizabeth McDonald

So unique! I dont know of many bakeries that do these single serving cheesecakes in so many different flavors! So glad this is only 5 min away from me. The cheesecakes are not too sweet and the flavors are all well balanced. I love that the base is an actual cookie. The people that work here are SUPER nice too. My only advice is to get there early because there are days where they sell out.

Ramazan Halit Acar

rude staff

Jessika Ormston

Everything she makes is amazing , my asked for a cotton candy cheesecake instead of a bday cake . Everyone should definitely try this place out :)

Amy Goodman

A+

Jena Tryfiak

What a delightful little spot in downtown Welland! All fresh, housemade mini and regular-sized cheesecakes in a variety of fruity and chocolatey flavors - something for everyone. INCLUDING VEGANS! It's often difficult to find a decadent dessert, so I was thrilled to discover Mama. I live in London so messaged her on Facebook to confirm they had vegan options available. She replied promptly and went out of her way to keep me updated. The vegan cheesecakes are topped fresh when you order, and that day she also had an Oreo flavor. Chocolate and plain bases were available with strawberry, cherry, raspberry, blueberry and chocolate toppings. She tells me they are made with cashews and chickpeas. Heaven! The first four cakes in the photo are vegan. I highly recommend this small local business. Mama is clearly passionate about what she does.

Localguide 1991

Best cheesecakes in town! Caitlin is so accommodating and considerate!!

Mary Dellenbusch

I have been looking for a chocolate chip cheesecake for over a year! Sara Lee's used to make them and they stopped. I called around to five different stores to see if they make them. Sadly, they didn't. A coworker of mine suggested this location. I'm ever so very grateful she did. Not only did they make a beautiful chocolate chip cheesecake but it is better than Sara Lee's! They have a new customer for sure. Thank you Caitlin!

Cichita Marisa

Worth the drive from Stoney Creek!! Got the Oreo cheesecake and 3 Keto cupcakes… delicious!!

Jamie Smith

Great cheesecake, keto options available

Dan Vince

Best cheese cake next to my wife's homemade cheesecake.

STUDENT MOM

Very cute little local business. Very nice owner. Delicious desserts! Hard to pick just one. They have a big variety of cheesecakes to choose from. Very welcoming place!

B F

My new addiction

Brenda Fowler

So many flavour combinations...all so delicious!

Brenda Kerezsi

Great variety of cheesecake. Has vegan and keto varieties as well. Staff are great!

Stephanie Duval

Wow! BEST Cheesecake ever! The variety of flavours to choose from is incredible and the taste....sensational! I don't see how anyone could be disappointed! The owner is very friendly and provides exceptional customer service. This was the first of many visits yet to come! Such a delight to learn of such a great dessert place in Welland! And the coffee was also delicious! I can't believe its taken me this long to experience this little piece of heaven on earth!

Tia Carlone

Amazing people !!! And amazing cheese cake :) so happy to be able to have such a wonderful local business ! Thank you guys :)

Albino Rhino (Albino Rhino Beer Review)

My Lord is this cheesecake good oh, sure it's a little pricey but so is most things that are small and artisanal but the damn cake is amazing and apparently she does keto cake!!

Amanda Oblinsky

Best cheesecake that I have ever had

sharon schaubel

Great selection. Always fresh and considerate of all types of diet. Friendly caring staff where everyone is family.

Ginette Brouwer

Amazing!

Layla Montgomery

I had a last minute Birthday order, and not only did Mama Misfits staff put together a wonderful assortment of cheesecakes at the end of their business day...They also delivered!

Slay

Guy was a total knob on the phone, didn't even bother ordering

Karen Bonham

Wowzo! The cheesecake tarts werea wonderful Mother's Day gift!

Vince Calvitto

Always above and beyond treats yummy

L Ferbrache

(Translated) Yummmmmmm !! (Original) Yummmmmmm!!

ChrisB Crunch

Best cheesecake desserts ever

Roxy Nicole

So Yummy

Debby Kulchar

First visit but sure wont be the last loved the cheesecake mmmm

Alyssa Fast

Delicious and creative desserts!

Dwayne Leach

First visit and I picked a cherry cheese cake for a gathering. It was the BEST category.cheese cake I have ever had. I will be back.

Frank Nelson

I don't really like cake, but I go out of my way to get Mama Misfits Cheesecakes; they're so good. You can't find better cakes or better people anywhere.

JC Le

This Cheesecake is a must try. It is so very good. Very friendly and personal staff. Pretty pricey. Loyalty card available.

Andrew Fisher (AJ)

Fantastic customer service, great pricing and just overall a very welcoming place. Keep up the good work!

David Wright

Nice people. Great product

Sunaina Saxena

So sick in bed and my boyfriend surprised me with my favourite.. cheesecake in little valentine day themed bites of deliciousness. I've been looking forward to this moment for awhile so I'm happy but I can't wait to make a visit soon so I can check out your menu and grab myself a slice. Thank you for making my day. I definitely recommend this place for all to try!

Carleen LeBlanc

Absolutely delicious. You can't get better value; if you were to make these cheesecakes at home, you'd probably spend the same price just on the ingredients! For the time and energy you'd save alone, these cheesecakes can't be beat!

Jocelyn Williams

Amazing as always! Picked up a large platter for the staff at our kids school. Looks so good.

Taylor Allen

Loovveee how cute and small this place was! My boyfriend and I just stopped by and bought some mini cheese cakes and OMG THEY WERE SO GOOD! I even got a keto one for myself and 100% going back for more soon!

Curt Solomon

Stupendous! Lots of choices, decent prices and friendly staff. There is nothing not to like about Mama Misfits.

Jerrah Toia

Best cheesecake Ever!

Kat Dupuis

What a honor to be able to support another local business. Amazing customer service, welcoming and friendly. Can't wait to enjoy the many different kinds of treats I purchased. Look forward to going back.

Sophia Borsellino

Love the cheesecakes so delicious . I would eat everything in that store cause it's that good . ????❤️

Capturing the Crumbs episodes

Amazing little local family run business that offers delicious cheesecakes (that sell out most days so go early ????) in multiple flavors and even has some fancy drinks now too as pictured! Tried this frozen chai latte and it was amazing!! Highly recommend stopping here when your strolling thru welland

#FeelGladMon

Better than any Cheesecake Factory around! Love the shop, and Caitlin has the best personality! Highly recommended!

Farley Hadley

My wife stumbled across Mama Misfit's when she was just getting started and it has become our go to place for cheesecake (or desserts/treats in general). The quality is simply outstanding, along with a very wide selection. I had a Twix cheesecake for my birthday, for example, and my wife spoils her co-workers with deliciousness. She has a quaint shop and service is always friendly and personal. Mmmmmm!

T Pas

Not impressed with customer service was left hanging and brought business elsewhere.

kari tattersall

So many choices!! Very nice little place! Very friendly staff

Jeff Ruller

The care and skill that goes into every mouth watering morsel is very evident. The variety of cheesecakes is almost overwhelming. Tasty, decadent treats were made for our wedding and thoroughly enjoyed by all our guests.

K D

Called twice about a week and a half ago to get a birthday cake for my mom and I never heard back. Disappointing because I know the cakes are good ????

Jeff Sider

Just had the Black Forest cheesecake for my son's 30th birthday and it was superb !!!

Crystal Smith

Omg!! The cheesecake here is to die for!! Not overly sweet, but oh so delicious!! Was worth the drive from Fergus to Welland !!

Danielle Ulch

Caitlin is an absolute sweetheart. The cheesecakes are always delicious and I finally got to try the no bake cheesecake for my birthday! It was delicious and had a chocolate covered strawberry inside.

Jr Phillip

Amazing cheesecake, Caitlin is doing an amazing job here. I love her super delicious creations, it is truly worth every penny. I picked up about a half dozen of her cheesecakes from a very unique valentines day selection and it was amazing.

Julie

Professional, reliable and great tasting food for a fair price. This is our go to for a Keto treat.

Trisha K

Amazing variety of cheesecakes.

rich morley

First time going here , definitely not the last

Ewa

Ordered white chocolate raspberry cheesecake and it was delicious! The owner was also very accommodating. Highly recommend. Thank you!

Fallon C

Amazing cheesecake. We ordered key lime raspberry. Amazing the whole family loved it

Freddy Thompson

Absolutely awesome!

Derick Gauthier

Legit the best place for any and all cheesecake needs

Rachel Emery

Our family tried a variety of the mini cheesecakes and they were a hit. Lots of different flavours to choose from and the mini size is perfect for an individual portion ( or for family gatherings ). Not TOO sweet, just sweet enough. I was a little disappointed that the key lime flavour wasn't more pronounced, but all the other flavours were spot on. We'll definitely be buying more in the future.

Reggie Proux

Absolute best!

Megan Brown

Best cheesecakes ever! Highly recommend! My favorite is white chocolate raspberry. Go run now and get some cheesecake and try it for yourself. You will not be disappointed!

Ljs Roti Shop

We totally love Mama Misfit's here at LJ's Roti Shop. We are big fans and supporters of Caitlin's delicious creations. Her cheesecakes make the best dessert for any occasion. She really does a great job representing Welland.

Ariel Guarino

The place looks very cute and the staff are super friendly. I ordered a vegan chocolate cheesecake and the owner told me it just finished cooking, so I'd have to refrigerate it for a bit. When I got home I couldn't wait to try it, so after a couple minutes in the fridge (because I couldn't wait any longer) I decided to give it a try. It was so good! I will definitely be coming back for more!

Paracord World CA Etsy

This is my go-to place for any cheesecake cravings!! Also having my own businesses I understand the importance of supporting Small Businesses so I have ordered from here for the last handful of birthday occasions and Yummy Yummy everytime! Lots of varieties to choose from! We have a Nut Allergry in the family and even though there are nut options on the menu, when I order directly and specify the Nut Allergy I have full trust that my order will be taken care of with no worries. Can't wait until our next opportunity to order again! Thank you for making such Yummy cheesecake!

Tim Young

Quick and cheery service. Fantastic cheesecake.

Miss Mel

Expensive! $19.00 for 6 mini two bite cheese cakes. Cute place, clean and friendly but those prices.

Ki Sobieraj

Fantastic service. Beautiful and delicious cheesecakes of all flavours. A definite must try.

Leelee

Cheesecake was delicious. Good prices.

Doug McKillop

Great product. Real hit for New Yeats Eve dessert

Ron

Very good cheese cake

bernie ermers

Awesome cheesecake!

Jordan Harding

Delicious cheesecake! They are also incredibly friendly and pickup felt very safe with all the COVID restrictions. I highly recommend!!!

David Brown

Amazing

Tom Patryluk

You have to try the butter tart Cheesecake oh ya her butter tarts are great by themselves.

Jenn Rozell

I had a not so great experience when speaking to someone on the phone,. The owner messaged me directly, apologized for what happened and delivered an apple crumble cheesecake to my door. She went well over above and beyond, and honest to goodness this was the absolute VERY BEST cheesecake I have ever had!

Brad Seymour

I give it a ten out of 5. Absolutely incredible cheesecake.

James McCombs

These cheesecake cupcakes are amazing!! Service was also excellent! Can't wait for my next excuse to stop in!!

Michael Landreau

Great staff! Amazing cheesecakes! 10/10

Cathy Higham

Such a large variety of lovely little cheesecake cupcakes!!! The presentation is just wonderful! The staff are very friendly! The customer service by the owner is excellent! Thank you so much!

Paul Taylor

My daughter made the purchase. We are new to the area. We will definitely be driving from St. Catharines to discover more of what they offer. We really enjoyed the cheese cake. Light and flavourful. Excellent!!

Jessica R

Delicious, I love contributing to small businesses!