Reviews of Sugar and Slice (Bakery)

David Angle

I have used Sugar and Slice for birthday cakes, gifts, cookie exchanges, and more. Always looks amazing, tastes great, and for a great value. Will certainly use again.

Jennifer Wallace

My sister had requested a carrot cake for her recent birthday, and Sugar & Slice did not disappoint. Not only was the cake delicious, the icing perfect, but the quantity was enough we got to enjoy it for a couple of days. The multi-layered cake was a big hit with the entire family. Of course, we couldn't grab a cake without also bringing home an assorted 6-pack of the scrumptious butter tarts -- absolutely the best in Niagara. I'm looking forward to more sweet treat orders from Michelle in my very near future.

Peggy St Angelo

Bree tarts are to die for! Oh the pastry.

Michael Jackson

If you want decadence, this is where you want to go. At first, I thought a 6 inch cake was small but Michelle made it with 4 layers. It was perfect. My request was a carrot cake with raisins made like a Spanish Bar cake. A small slice with a cup of tea or coffee and you are in heaven! Thank you Michelle!!

Josiah Jordan

I have known Michelle for almost 20 years now. She is honest and her cakes are delicious. I was able to tell her exactly what i wanted and she was able to make it happen - even for a person who has specific food allergies.! Will be ordering for another birthday soon!

Haley Armstrong- Laframboise

Amazing cakes, she created exactly what we wanted, couldn’t be happier!!

Valerie Freeman

I did not a very good experience ordering from this bakery. I ordered online and went to pick up at their location. When I arrived they told me the cake was not ready. They said they were having problems with their online ordering system. They said they would make the cake and deliver it to the hotel I was staying at. I said that was fine and waited for the cake to be delivered. The cake was delivered in a reasonable amount of time but the quality was subpar. I ordered the chocolate vanilla layer cake. The vanilla layers were very dry and the icing was way too sweet. Not impressed with my experience.

Laura Muller-Bot

The cake was beautiful and presentation was lovely. My biggest issue with the tiramisu cake is that it was extremely sweet and had additional icing. We were expecting a tiramisu cake to be more traditional.

John Grenn

Great quality and service, I highly recommend Sugar and Slice!

Samad Hassan

We had a 'cake smash' photoshoot for our son's first birthday. The cake was from Sugar and Slice and it was one of the best cakes I've ever had: it was creamy, fresh, and a great bright blue color(I only wish I had pics before he smashed it). My wife and I appreciated they took the time to make it look so elegant even though it was going to get smashed...the attention to detail was refreshing to see. We'll be going back just as soon as we find another reason to get a cake.

Susan Sakowski

Very Very good butter tarts.

monica carroll

AMAZING PRODUCTS! Threw a party with desserts provided by Michelle, and they were all amazing. She had variety for everyone, including those with allergies. She was responsive and really made sure that we got everything we wanted. Would recommend to everyone and anyone!

Deborah Graham

Very happy with the service and quality! So many choices!! My new go-to!

MCC

We have used Sugar and Slice for birthday cakes and other functions. Has never disappointed in look or taste of products. Definitely recommend her.

Peggy Zavitz

Discovered Sugar & Slice at the Grimsby Market and we are definitely repeat customers. The peach crumble pie is amazing, yummy cheddar scones are perfect with a bowl of soup, and the magic squares are moist and delicious. But the best by far are the ooey-gooey, fabulous buttertarts. Great quality and value for all the products. Michelle also did a custom ladybug cake (chocolate/vanilla layers) and the most adorable ladybug sugar cookies that everyone raved about.

Mallory Campbell

We use Sugar and Slice for all of our family events and holidays. Highly recommend!

Diane Gin

Most amazing butter tarts! Great customer service on a last min order .

Ross Wallace

This is the best kept secret in the Niagara area. We received a cake that was absolutely a piece of art. The taste of the cake itself... and the the butter cream icing was phenomenal. There is nothing anywhere that meets the high standards that are set here. Try this bakery...you will not be disappointed. I might add that it was delivered right to our house... which was great especially during this current Covid lockdown.