Reviews of Eat My Sweets Bakery/100% Peanut & Tree-Nut Free (Bakery)

Samantha Samuels

All the items are consistently very tasty. I like the blackout brownie in particular because it is rich and indulgent.

Jodi Cote

If I could give them 0 I would. I'm not impressed by this Bake Shop. I emailed respectively asking if they could do me a pot themed cake. They responded telling me basically they refuse to do that design because they are "family oriented". Well if you look on their site, they have bullet belt themed cakes and alcohol themed cakes. I've never felt more flabbergasted. Dont lie to me. Just say you have a real issue with weed. A personal issue. Done push me away and tell me my theme is going to potentially put a dent in your reputation. They also said that its family and kids browsing cakes. Well you have different sections. Make a mature section. It's simple. All I got was excuses and 0 responces after trying to seek clarification. Very rude. Dont reccomend.

Nick K

This place is a hidden gem. Even if you don't have tree nut allergies, this place is for you. The staff is awesome and they really know their stuff. They are so proud of their hard work, and it really shows. I was a test subject for a new treat they were developing for the holidays, and I can't wait to try the finished product in a few weeks. People need try the cookie dough brownie. It was so good, I didn't even take a picture. Thanks for a great experience ladies!

Wendy H

Got the original tiramisu, it was even better than expected, wasn't overwhelmingly sweet either. Hoping to visit again someday!

J K

Apple pie was amazing. Squares are great as well.

Desmond Forde (Dexter)

Lovely little shop

Jassie S.

We had an amazing experience going here. I went here with my girlfriend for some dessert and was delighted as so how many options for treats there were. We got one of their brownies, two small cheesecake thingys and a cupcake. The cupcake was really good and so did the two small cheesecake thingys. The brownie was especially good too. We also saw how many different preserve flavours there were and were inclined to get a few. The service was absolutely great and I definitely got a nice, kind and friendly small shop vibe from the woman working, who I think was the owner. She was very nice! Overall I would 100% percent recommend this place for some nice tasty desserts and good service.

Cynthia Welsh

Great price...very cute and tasty. Good size for parties.

Sarah M

Absolutely love this bakery! They have quickly become the "go-to" in our home for peanut free treats! Not only is everything delicious, but the staff is so incredibly friendly!

MC Henry

Excellent Quiches! I was not much of a quiche fan before but Michelle turned me into one! Best quiche I've ever had. I had the quiche lorraine, mushroom & swiss, and spinach & feta! All of them are great! ????????????????????

Gracie Bumblebee

Great quality, excellent atmosphere, and most of all the best sweets in town! Everything is truly peanut and tree-nut free - Michelle and her team even make sure no ingredient (down to the flour and sugar) contains warning labels for possible contact with peanuts and/or tree-nuts. If you look through her portfolio, Michelle is truly gifted in custom cake creations - go check out the life-size guitar cake photo; it's my favourite!

Joseph Marsilla

I think I've tried every kind of awesome treat that Michelle creates, and believe you me, each one is delicious. Definitely the best dessert bakery & custom cakes place in Mississauga. (Hint Hint - if you like organic home made butter tarts , no one makes them better!!)

Miracle Pope

Yummy treats!

Andrea Tenk

I recently ordered two cakes from Eat My Sweets Bakery, one custom tall cake and a standard 6" round. The cakes were beautifully designed and delicious. We will definitely be returning for future special events. Thanks very much for helping make our birthday celebrations very special.

Lauren Christerra

Wonderful mom and daughters own this place! They are sooo sweet ???? just like their treats! Highly recommend.

Kiara The Baby Rottweiler

Amazing treats!!! You've got to try it!

Chris Chmielewski

Amazing dessert place. So much to choose from and i think every item was $3. Soo good. Definitely give it a try!

Jenny Bee

We bought a small assortment of squares for Thanksgiving, and there was something for everyone's taste! I loved the ginger blondie (buttery, chewy ginger spice!), my mother bogarted the cherry oat squares, and everyone loved the jammin' shortbread (just like grandma used to make). The pumpkin cheesecake blondie was ok, but not the favourite. We picked up a couple jams while in the shop, and so far have only opened the blackberry sage -- but sweet mercy it's delicious. The sage flavour is delicate but an excellent addition to the blackberries. All the staff in the shop were super friendly, even the ladies in the back came up a little to joke around with us. Very clean, with sanitizer and gloves available by the entrance. This may quickly become our new weekly treat.

J Watt96

Michelle's bakery is the finest quality of baking you could taste. Not only is she an expert at baking delicious goods, but her customer friendly environment makes all feel at home when they enter. If you're looking for 5 star service, you need to go to Eat My Sweets!

Miriam Weerasooriya

Ordered 24 photo image cupcakes (chocolate, vanilla & lemon) which turned out pretty well. Should have ordered more lemon since they were gone quickly! Also ordered a 9 inch strawberry cheesecake which was nice and light- only issue is the graham crust (which I love!) was a bit too thick, even for me. Other than that, really happy with the purchase and would definitely order again.

Ismaeel Mirza

Really great bakery and you don't have to worry about peanuts or nuts at all! The owner is super nice and so is her mom. Highly recommend it. Ordered a Oreo cake and not only was it an affordable fair price, but the decoration was exactly what I had in mind!

Sam Gomez

We used this bakery for cupcakes for a daycare and they were very well received. They indicated they were 100% nut free (required for school/day care) and they tasted great. Will be using them again and their store smells delicious!

Myro Teo

I love Tiramisu and Rolo brownie squares.????

Natila Zehra Farooqi

Delicious Cake! My brother was really happy with his birthday cake. You can tell Eat My Sweets take great care in their creations, they even added an extra little detail which we did not ask for. 10/10

Brandon Osmond

Michelle makes the best brownies and squares in the Greater Toronto Area. Hands down. Great place!

Mary Toma

Honestly this place is amazing. I ordered cupcakes for my sons daycare class for his birthday and from what the teachers and son said it was amazing. Michelle was so helpful with what I wanted and accommodating to my busy schedule. Sooooo pleased with the service I received only thing that I have to say that I wish was different is for them to open a location closer to Port credit area but still worth the drive.

Joy B

Great customer service and freshly baked goods! A hidden gem in Streetsville! My favs are the lemon squares and Rolo brownies.

Lovpreet Dhaliwal

Delicious sweets!

D F

These cake was so delicious, moist, fresh, and was masterpiece man I cant stop thinking about it lol. These cake was bought for my wifes baby shower and thank God I told her to save me a piece. Like I mentioned before It was really good that I had to steal her piece she saved for her lol. I know for future events I am going to order another cake from "Eat my sweets bakery" Thank you again for making these cake amazing for the special day!

Grace Gwynne-Vaughan

The best brownies I’ve ever had!!

Expect Better at HomeRunProperties DOT Ca

My wife and I have been frequenting this wonderful bakery for several years now because our dogs are groomed next door at Crowned Canines. So the location is convenient for us whenever it is time for the dogs to be groomed. Over the years, we have tried their various sweets ranging from their delicious line of brownies, cookies, cupcakes, butter tarts and mini cheesecakes. The service has always been friendly and courteous. The Baker herself ( I keep forgetting her name ...my memory is so bad in my old age ) is always happy to answer my questions while serving us. My friends and neighbours have also visited because of their " Nut Free" promise. So many cakes have been ordered for children's birthdays and special occasions. Their prices are so reasonable. You will be able sample and taste a wide variety of their treats whenever you have those sweet tooth cravings !!! It is another local mom & pop business that is working their way through these crazy times. So treat yourselves and drop in for a visit and let us all know what your thoughts are. This bakery hits a HomeRun right out of the park !!!

Sarah O'Brien

Fun place, excellent service, yummiest treats! An endless variety of goodies for any occasion. Creative custom cakes and so much, much more! Your sweet tooth will be satisfied!

Joanne B

Amazing desserts and wonderful staff! They go above and beyond in terms of the overall customer experience! Would highly recommend this bakery in a heart-beat!

Dorothy Ip

Best baked goods in town (literally)! Tree nut peanut free a bigger bonus. Owner, Michelle is the sweetest! Just ordered a huge platter for the dessert table at our wedding. Can't wait to share with the guests. Her chocolate cupcakes and smores squares are bomb! Must try!

Sara Delgado

Michelle! What a star! Loved her amazing customer service from when we first interacted to when I picked up the cupcakes. I ordered 50 Strawberries and Cream cupcakes for my sister's bridal shower, and they were a huge hit! Definitely going to be a returning customer.

Pearline Bartlett

Bought a birthday cake for my daughter in law's birthday. I told Michelle just a little bit about her, the colours she likes etc. I got the most beautiful cake fit for a princess. We loved it! The entire team was awesome too and it was a pleasure to meet them all. Wonderful and talented people. Sonia

Lesley Cornelius

Probably the best tasting custom birthday cake I've ever had!

Kevin Pollard

A great find. The flavours are amazing.

Jamie Hope

It's hard to believe my husband and I found a place where we can walk in and get whatever our hearts desire. Allergy sensitive bakeries are few and far between. Since everything looks so delicious, it was nice to order one of everything worry free. Delicious treats, friendly staff and an appreciated bakery. Thanks for thinking of those with allergies.

Robert Graham

For anyone that has a nut allergy, this is where you need to go. My daughter has a peanut allergy and being able to buy cookies and cakes knowing that the staff is not only aware but take precautions, makes a big difference. The products are top quality and the staff very friendly and helpful. Go here and buy stuff!

S Patel (patelsr)

We had a pandemic birthday and rather than drop a cake on porch we thought we would take a bunch of small desserts for the birthday girl and family. They are nut free environment but no desserts that are dairy and egg free. Will not even take special orders for dairy free and egg free which is understandable. Quite a few options still available when we walked in a few minutes before closing on a weekday. Picked up two Birthday Squares, two brownies, two butter tart squares and two cookies and cream. We picked up two extra for our home for those eat eggs and dairy - salted caramels. The family and the birthday girl loved all of the squared and specially the cookies and cream. Our household enjoyed the salted caramel as well. We did bring to room temperature as instructed and warmed up in a microwave however the caramel still hadn’t loosened.

Ashley Tattersall

Michelle and her team are absolutely amazing to work with and take all the stress out of making sweet treats for a birthday party or any event. We found Eat My Sweets Bakery when we were looking for a peanut free bakery to make a cake for my son's first birthday. Since then, Eat My Sweets has been our go-to for our cake orders. Michelle's cakes are delicious and fluffy and her buttercream frosting is light and creamy. Michelle and her team have always given the personal touch when decorating our cakes. I truly recommend this bakery for those catering to nut allergies or just people who like to eat good cakes!

shanny Marie

They made a cake and cupcakes for our wedding back in 2019. Amazing omg everyone loved them so much. We will be ordering more to celebrate our anniversary they were just that good. I have a friend who has a severe peanut allergy and I just wasn't willing to take the risk of any cross contamination so this place is perfect.

Samantha Phelps

Love love love this place! Had a custom made cupcake birthday cake made for my nephews 1st birthday and it looked absolutely beautiful! Everyone loved it and said it was delicious! Thank you so much! ????

Linda Pruessen

Eat My Sweets created an amazing cake for a small graduation celebration (to replace the big celebration that can't happen because of Covid!). Getting an online quote was easy and quick; sorting out the look of the cake was easy, with Michelle's help; and the cake looked and tasted delicious. I happily recommend Eat My Sweets. They'll be my first call the next time I need baked goods!

Randa H

We just had a custom made cake for my 4 year old’s bday and it was amazing!! It looked and tasted wonderful and was a complete hit at the party! Totally recommend them! Thank you guys so much!

Tony Lorusso

Ordered my nieces June 9th confirmation cake and cupcakes from Eat My Sweets and it was fresh and delicious!!! From placing the order to picking up the order, the service was friendly and 1st class. Thank you Michelle and your wonderful team for making this day special and safe (nut free) for my niece.

Jackie S

Amazing and delicious peanut free cake for my son’s birthday party. Will definitely order again!

Amy Pitkins

I don't live locally but stopped in because my daughter has a nut allergy and can rarely eat at bakeries. I'm so glad I did! Everything we got (and it was a lot) was absolutely incredible. It may be a good thing I don't live closer. I'd have a hard time not stopping there every day! Can't say enough good things about this bakery.

Nadin Kurukchi

Delicious cake, beautiful designs and professional staff. Thank you for the amazing cake!

Laura B

What a great experience from start to finish! Eat My Sweets brought our mini mermaid cupcake vision to life in a beautiful and delicious way for my daughter's fifth birthday. There was a nut allergy in the group of little party goers, and I felt very confident serving these. Several parents complimented and asked where to get these cupcakes! Quick responses from the bakery, reasonably priced, and open to all suggestions. Couldn't be happier. Did I mention the fondant mermaid tails? Just awesome.

Melanie Filiatrault

I ordered my son's 1st birthday cake from Eat My Sweets because my cousin's daughter has a tree nut allergy and I didn't want her to be left out. Little did I know that a few days after I ordered the cake, my 1 year old had a peanut reaction, so I was so happy that I knew that I didn't have to worry about him eating his own birthday cake! Michelle was super helpful and made some great suggestions for the cake, which was delicious! My father, who does not really like chocolate cake, took home 4 pieces of it! I will definitely be ordering cakes and treats from Eat My Sweets in the future.

Taylor M.

Michelle and her associates at Eat My Sweets Bakery are professionals who know what they are doing. Every product that I have had of their, which includes cookies, scones, cupcakes, and MANY more (Lol) have been delicious! The customer service is excellent and I would strongly recommend Eat My Sweets to anyone in need of baked goods for any type of function. Will definitely be back for more delicious treats!

Bri Shirakawa

Michelle did my cupcakes for my wedding and I have nothing but amazing things to say about her. Her service was fantastic, any questions I had she answered promptly and nicely, the day of she set everything up beautifully, the cupcakes were absolutely stunning and tasted so so so delicious. And the price was really good as well. I have been in a few times prior to the wedding and have always been greeted by michelle and her mom or sister with a friendly smile, and delicious hand made treats. I cant say enough good things. Will definitely be using them again.

Shannon Komar

Ordered custom hockey jersey cookies for my son's hockey team (each player had a cookie with their name and number). The cookies looked great and tasted even better. Michelle was very easy to deal with when ordering the cookies, and her and her staff were all fantastic when picking them up. Will definitely order more cookies in the future!

Trevor Bell

My girlfriend wanted to get a weed themed birthday cake made for me. This place said it goes against their brand as they are a "family oriented business." Yet you can go on their website and find a picture of a Jack Daniel's whiskey themed cake. It is scientifically proven that alcohol is extremely more dangerous than weed. This company will promote alcoholism but will overlook the health benefits of weed. What's up with that? Marijuana is a LEGAL substance now. You'd think they would get with the times. Its 2020, not 1920.

Rawan Al-Baldawi

Great bakery with amazing cakes that are nuts free!

K Sibs

Purchased some assorted brownies, blondies & mini cheesecakes. Delicious & such a good size per portion.

John jJanowicz

OMGosh!. Ordered 3 pies and a quiche this past Saturday. The fillings were excellent, exactly what you expected...The crust though was my ultimate over the top flavor, texture and dream crust .Such a great product they put out there. After years of purchasing peanut-free products elsewhere you have made me a believer that peanut-free and great flavor is attainable. Cannot sign off without praising the ownership and staff..Truly professional in every aspect of the word. From warm friendly telephone conversation to place my order up to showing me my product like a bottle of fine wine, packing it professionally to holding the door open as I left with my treasures Keep doing what you do...cu soon

Zein Hancock

You come for the Nut Free Cakes and you’re delighted with the discovery of the best dessert place in Mississauga. Period. From simply divine chocolate cake, to strawberry shortcake to shadow cake, we’ve tried them all at this truly One Of a Kind Bakery. Always perfect delicious cakes, cupcakes and desserts custom made to exceed expectations. Not to mention the warm welcome by owners and staff at this delightful family run bakery. Always a treat. Just give them a try and keep coming back for more. A hidden gem in the heart of Streetsville.

Amandeep Grewal

Simply amazing! I ordered a picture cake for my 5th anniversary and it was made on time, looked amazing (my wife loved it!), and tasted great! I use to get all my cakes from another bakery but their cakes have gone downhill over the years, so I wanted to try another bakery. I found it!