Reviews of Romeo & Juliet's Cafeé & Bakery (Bakery)

Buffalo Guy

What a delightful place. So cute and soooo cozy. Great outside patio seating, fresh coffee, an amazing bakery full of desserts, and a friendly and fast staff. Had the triple chocolate cake and a steamed froth espresso. We had a great time and 100% will visit again! Check it out!

Peter Nagy

This place is always great. Friendly, knowledgeable staff, delicious food, nice atmosphere... What more could you all for?

James Santos

Tons of dessert selections. They all looked great. Wish we could try them all. Would love to come back and try their full menu for dinner someday!

Bethony Kay

I ordered the Pizza Portobello and Bruschetta di Filippo. PIzza was great. Mushrooms were delicious. Bruschetta, not so much. Dry and the cheese was overcooked.

Seth Payne

Honestly this is my favorite restaurant in Buffalo, we come here for my birthday every year I can. The pizza is phenomenal as is the service. If you get the paninis which are so good, ask about the different mayos the garlic mayo is where it’s at imo. Highly underrated!

Sridhar Mane

Love the lobster ravioli here. My wife likes the deserts from here a lot.

Therese Deutschlander

This is such a quaint restaurant with the most amazing food and wonderful staff. The portions are large (and delicious!) so plan on sharing but definitely check it out. You won't be disappointed and you will return.

Kristina Long

I went here for the first time the other night and I have been craving more of their tortellini ever since. The food was delicious and was a good portion size. The atmosphere was very laid back and friendly. The decor was a bit interesting, but in a “it’s so quirky it’s cute” kind of way. Overall would definitely recommend to a friend!

Robert Heil

We walked in with a group of 12.... No problem! The service from Lauren was excellent and everything came out fresh, fast and delicious! Had the Spinachi Salad with chicken...amazing! We ordered 3 Stuffed Hot Peppers to share.... Total deliciousness!

Carmela Petrina S

Food is amazing large portion sizes, great selection of Italian deserts

Zane Stringer

The pizza was simply fantastic, the house wines were decent & very reasonably priced, and the dessert was to die for. Highly recommended, can’t wait to go back.

Deema Sous

Excellent Italian restaurant plus they have a healthy menu

Sabrina Pena Young

Always a favorite spot. My kids and I share a pizza and desserts. Reasonable prices. Can go to the restaurant side or the cafe. Chocolate cake is delicious. One bathroom in back. Friendly staff. Everyone needs to go to Romeo and Juliets when they go to North Buffalo.

David Udin

Excellent pizza and pannini. Restaurant has a wide Italian selection, also excellent. Bread, cookies and pastry shine.

Emely Lopez

The bread is amazing, reminds me of home due to its artisan looks and taste. MUST try the ricotta Nutella mini tart. I loved that it wasn't too sweet. Is now in my list of top desserts. They have a great selection of beverages and the location is great (Hertel Ave).

Love Life

Very friendly Hard working people they put love in everything that they do Thanks For making father Sicari Birthday cake

Paul Melville

All of the food at Romeo & Juliet’s is fantastic. But the panini’s are the best in Buffalo. The Italian cookies are great as well as all of the deserts they have (which is a lot)! The staff is friendly and the service is excellent! Easy five stars!

Gabriel Lopez

The menu is delicious across the board. Knocks the socks off Italian restaurants in the area that are charging three times as much. If you go out to eat because you like food, this is a restaurant for you.

Angelo Grande

Fantastic pizza, panini and baked goods second to none!

Shawn White

The food was amazing, the service was amazing it was a beautiful day to sit outside. I've always came for lunch this was my first time coming for dinner and it was delicious. On Wednesday they have a discount on a bottle of wine ????

Lara Seniw

Service and food could not have been better! Absolutely loved our girls dinner.

Elizabeth Mannion

Excellent pizza and service!

Adam Mutch

Very delicious New York style pizza. A new addition to the Buffalo pizza list.

Mary Hunter

Best thin crust pizza in north Buffalo, or should I say the city!

Beatrix Balogh

Got the margherita pizza and the pepperoni - by far the best pizza I've ever had. The dough was absolutely amazing, super light and fluffy, but flavorful. We had a few slices as leftovers and reheated them the next day - no change in taste at all! The dough and cheese and toppings were still delicious!

Odell Buggs

The deserts were excellent!!

Richard Martone

Sauce is very good, not sweet but delicious. Pastas are satisfying and servings are generous. Brie appetizer is worth a mention, too.

Stephen Rudberg

You can't go wrong if you are looking for authentic, Italian food at this place. Service is friendly. Best known for its pizza, I ordered the Margarita Pizza which was oven baked to perfection topped with delicious melted mozzarella and other cheeses with Basel. Delicious and highly recommended.

Parth Patel

We ordered two cakes here - sinful chocolate and one was chocolate raspberry. The quality is really good. All of the guests liked the cakes. I would recommend them, just found the $35 a bit pricey but the quantity is huge too, so I guess no complains there.

Fnord Wolfe

So many people rave about thier pizza so I thought I was in for a treat. At best it is mediocre. The dough is good but the sauce and cheese seems to be very low quality. The price was a little high as well for the size of the pizza. Bakery was good but it sells out of stuff fast and apparently the two locations have differant options. Staff is polite but not all that helpful.

Emma P

Good food, attentive staff, and at a great place on Hertel. It can be a bit difficult to find parking near by, but it wasn't too bad at the time I went. The bread is served with this great dip that I wish I could replicate!

Christopher Walsh

Friendly staff, cozy atmosphere, amazing italian dishes and desserts that are reasonably priced. Try the Asiago gnocchi with red pepper vodka sauce, delightful.

Kiersten Slater

I ordered the Eggplant Parmigiana to go, delicious and large portions - Definitely got my money’s worth! Chocolate peanut butter cake was equally as good! Food also was done quickly, I ordered through Grubhub which estimated 30-40 minutes but was done in about 15/20. And friendly staff on top of every thing!

Bob

Love the pizza, panini, pasta e fagioli. Espresso and coffee drinks or wine with dessert on the caffe patio are also fantastic.

Sherri Darrow

The most authentic southern Italian restaurant in Buffalo. My favorites are biscotti, breads, eggplant parmigiana, and wonderful thin dough pizza.

Angela Jones

Food was not good

Patty Crescimano

Food was fabulous and the waitress excellent and kind

T Rebecca

Food is always consistently great here. High quality, fast service and cost friendly. Highly recommend their pepperoni pizza, cannolis and chocolate cake. Can’t go wrong with their paninis either.

Michelle Souza

Excellent food, nice atmosphere, friendly staff.

Carol Ann Spano

Picked up cassata cake to take home. Made coffee, all ready to enjoy the cake. I have never seen a staler piece of cake in my life. The whipped cream actually cracked and fell off. Dry as can be. They had the nerve to charge $5.00 for this. Very disappointed.

megan banfield

What a wonderful little place! Just passing through and wanted to find a small cafe. Food was AMAZING and service dog friendly! The owner made the entire experience. He was super friendly and accommodating to our Guide Dog pups in training. I wish I lived closer. If you are going through Buffalo, this cafe is a MUST!

Vanessa Scott

The desserts I choose to try were delicious, the staff however was not accommodating. When I came to the counter it appeared they were in a meeting and looked over their shoulders and ignored me....it bothered without a doubt. At least acknowledge customers and let them know you will be with them shortly

Jack Norton

Always fine food.

Jesse Alguire

Absolutely delicious food, beautiful scenery and very romantic setting. Great date idea!

Rex KOEPPEN

Our second visit. Calamari was perfect. Chicken Cesar was on point. Our first visit had great dishes as well. Wine was on sale! The Cheese Ravioli and meatball did disappoint. Everything had been hand crafted until I was served purchased ravioli and what appeared to be a premade meatball. It was on the specials board.the sauce saved it but stick with the classic menu. Cheers to a great dining venue.

Ryan Fortner

Good food and the servers were friendly and attentive. I could definitely see myself going here again.

Kim Marchese

We were looking for somewhere to eat and happen to drive by and thought we’d try it. So glad we did! Felt like home! Food was delicious! Will definitely come back again!

Patrick Occhino

Great bakery.

Chris Washington

I had the lobster Ravioli and it was incredible, also had their lasagna which was very delicious, however the lobster ravioli is just to die for. I'll definitely be returning often.

Caroline Aungst

Never disappoints! Fresh, full flavors and generous portions. Excellent service as well.

Nicholas Headley

only had the dessert, but they were so moist and delicious.

scott cramer

Clean casual environment with an Italian / cecilian like theme... the warm Bistro like environment is second only to they're deliciously authentic menu.. they also make homemade Breads and desserts from scratch that are outstanding... great place for a family outing or a night out with your significant other.. this is a place you will most likely want to visit time and time again. Even if it's just to stop in for the occasional takeout dessert.

Dana Bowens

Great food, nice atmosphere, good service☺️

Pamela C

I recommend this place it is a must if your in north buffalo. Delicious food excellent desserts. The staff makes you feel like your family. I loveeee this place.

Rosalyn Rivera

Between a friend and I, we bought four different baked goods. Each one was magnificent. Once we walked in, we could tell this was an Italian bakery. The employee was very helpful and explained each of the pastries that seemed interesting to us. The only regret I have is not getting more.

Kentreil Champion

Love the name. Perfect location. Cute and quaint. Nice selection. Loved connoli. Only reason not 4 or 5 is because it was a quick stop in. Will give further review when I return and sit down to eat

Drew Sweetser

The food is amazing here and the service is top notch. I highly recommend trying this place out if you're in the area.

danielle thompson

I have ordered take out and delivery through Uber Eats MANNnny times, also 1 dine in experience. Every single time it's consistently DELICIOUS. Fresh bread and tasty Italian dishes including paninis.

Paula G

Great pizza and salads! Will definitely be back

Gabrielle Gramaglia

Meagan is the greatest waitress. So personable and friendly. They make you feel like Family and at home. She always Remembers my order and food is always delicious